Terrelle Pryor

The NCAA is already a joke and now the NFL is following in its footsteps with the disciplinary action against Ohio State star Terrelle Pryor.

Pryor's unique situation has put the NFL in a tough spot and once again commissioner Roger Goodell has ham-handedly tried to split the difference.

The NFL has ruled Pryor eligible for the supplemental draft (which it postponed for several days while trying to figure out how to deal with Pryor), but has imposed a bizarre and probably illegal five game suspension on the former Buckeye QB 1.

The convoluted and illogical rationale for the NFL's decision is that the league is merely copying the NCAA's disciplinary action against Pryor (five games beginning this fall for illegally selling memorabilia) and didn't want to reward the QB for evading NCAA "justice." With his pending draft status, Pryor has had to meekly accept the punishment and not raise any objections to its blatant unfairness lest he jeopardize his appeal to teams by being deemed "difficult." His situation really does hearken to a time when the labor was supposed to obey the master's every command submissively and without complaint.

A couple of points and questions regarding the NFL's punishment:

1) The NFLPA, the NFL and others have taken pains to say that Pryor's punishment is in no way a precedent. But with or without this blessing, the action does indeed set a precedent whether it is intended or not. The bar has been set, and in the famous legal maxim, you can't unring the bell.

2) For what violations is Pryor being punished? The original "crime" of selling memorabilia or the larger institutional violations that force the resignation of head coach Jim Tressel? If it is the latter, than that investigation is still ongoing and hasn't been concluded. If it is the former, then it is disproportionate to the infraction. The whole reason Pryor got the 5 game suspension was to put a better face on the fact that OSU and the NCAA allowed Pryor to play in the Sugar Bowl after the problems came to light. Pryor was willing to forgo half of his senior season to play in the game (as was Tressel, OSU, the NCAA and the BCS). Unfortunately for Pryor and OSU, Tressel was running a very unclean program and forced to resign between the Sugar Bowl win and the 2011 season, prompting Pryor to reconsider his commitment to play for a team in 2011 which was under NCAA investigation, would have a new coach, and for which Pryor would miss half the season. There seems little doubt that had Pryor know in December 2010 that Tressel would not be back and the Buckeyes would be facing significant sanctions moving forward that Pryor would have taken the Sugar Bowl suspension in lieu of the 5 games the following season (and declared his eligibility for the 2011 draft).

3) The idea that the NFL is now committed to enforcing NCAA discipline on players who evade college punishment is laughable. Reggie Bush just returned his Heisman Trophy and USC forfeited wins and the 2004 national championship, but Bush never missed a minute of playing time. If the NFL is serious about its newfound interest in holding college players to account, doesn't it have to suspend Bush for several games as well? And the burgeoning scandal at the U. would, by the same logic, imperil the playing status of former U players and current NFL stars like Vilma, Beason and who knows who else (Reggie Wayne? Antrell Rolle? McGahee? Kellen Winslow? Ed Reed? Vernon Carey? DJ Williams?) for accepting cash, prostitutes, and other illegal activities for which they were never held to account by the college rulemesiters.

4) Shouldn't the NFL be similarly concerned with disciplining wayward college coaches for their illicit doings? Pete Carroll jumped ship from USC when an NCAA investigation uncovered widespread institutional wrongdoing, resulting in forfeited wins, loss of scholarships, and a ban on post-season play. Based on Pryor's NFL punishment, shouldn't Carroll be sanctioned by the NFL?

The new collective bargaining agreement was supposed to end such arbitrary disciplinary decisions by Roger Goodell. His Terrelle Pryor decision shows that not only is that not the case, but that unequal punishment is still alive and well in the NFL.