Tuesday, February 16, 2016

A Dome?

One of the overlooked minor details in the Rams move back to LA is that Stan Kroenke's relocation proposal was for a domed stadium. I'm not sure what the rationale is for a dome in perpetually sunny LA (will it increase the flexibility/utility of using the stadium for other purposes besides football) but it will be a shock to TV viewers who tune into a game only to discover the artificial light and artificial turf of the LA stadium. Showing off my East Coast bias - one of the most aesthetically pleasing things about watching the 4:00 pm (eastern) games in November and December is to see the sunny skies, warm weather, and green grass of games being played in San Diego, San Francisco and Oakland (with the dirt cutout infield). But the LA domed stadium will offer views nothing like that. What a pity.

A Much Different Time

Notre Dame Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Lattner has passed away. His obituary hearkens back to a time long gone - when Heisman Trophy winners would leave the NFL to serve in the military. It is inconceivable that such a thing would happen today - even for players from the service academies -  and as this nation is "at war" with terrorists. And for those that want to cite Pat Tillman, he was not a top college player (in addition to winning the Heisman Lattner was drafted 7th overall), and in fact is the exception that proves the rule.

Monday, February 15, 2016

Who's to Blame?

Did Richard Cohen really blame the police for the hundreds of Middle Eastern refugees who sexually assaulted German women on New Year's Eve in Cologne?


The Cologne incident, too, while larger in scope, has not — or not yet — been repeated. There, too, the police have learned from their mistakes.

What, pray tell, were the police's mistakes (note the plural Cohen uses)? Not racially profiling MIddle Eastern migrants? Presuming that refugees would tend to be law abiding? Allowing migrants to assemble in large groups? Downplaying the incident initially so as not to draw attention to it?

It''s a pity Cohen doesn't elaborate on this important point.

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

Whoops, I Did It Again!

Unwitting Ironic Statement of the Night

Marco Rubio finally admitting to and apologizing for his robotic repeating of his talking points during Saturday night's presidential debate.

"So, listen to this: That will never happen again. It will never happen again."

As Chris Christie would say, there it is again! The repetitious talking point! Even when he's apologizing for repeating his same points over and over....he's repeating his same points over and over.

Monday, February 08, 2016

Super Bowl Post-Mortem

Wow, didn't see that outcome happening. Not the meager Denver offense, which was as mediocre as expected. It was the complete inability of the Panthers offensive line to stop a rampaging Von Miller and Demarcus Ware. I understood why a depleted Patriots line with undrafted players and free agent castoffs couldn't stop Ware and especially Miller. But I never saw coming Newton geting so teed off on. 
Honestly, the Panthers looked out of sync and sorts all game. From the penalties to the missed field goal, to the dropped passes, to the lack of execution they just looked off.

Other random thoughts:

* Forget all the inane questions about whether Roger Goodell would let his sons play football. What do you think his answer will be when his multibillion business is predicated on negligent and safety-averse parents letting their children play youth football. The more relevant question in the lead up to the big game would have been what he thought about the propriety of NFL teams taking money from the DoD to "honor" military veterans and promote the armed forces. It came to mind after the repeated shots of the US soldiers in Afghanistan, the flyover, and the presenting of the colors.

* The kids spawned in the euphoria of past super bowl victories was at first interesting from a statistical point but quickly got very, very creepy. Is this part of the Goodell plan to breed/rely on the next generation of football participating children?

* Forget yellow and red cards and 2 personal fouls getting a player ejected. How about eliminating the bizarre rule where a personal foul inside the 15 yard line only results in a half the distance to the goal penalty. Talib's face mask penalty was one of the more vicious you'll see, made worse by his admission that he did it on purpose knowing that it was only going to cost him about a yard or two. Contrast that with the Panthers' grasping defensive holding penalty on third down at the end of the game that gave the Broncos an automatic first down that they then converted into a TD. What was the more dangerous and egregious play? And yet, which was a more substantive consequence?

* Poor Coldplay.

* Was it a conspiracy or sympathy? I don't recall CBS ever showing a graphic of Peyton Manning's Dilfer like stats: 13-23, 144 yards. 

* Speaking of which, while CBS was showing graphics of Manning's historical records, viewers at home did not see the final play of the game. Which Nantz described as a "merciful" end, which is funny because with about 5 minutes to go the Panthers had the ball for what could have been a game winning drive - so I'm not sure what game Nantz was watching.

* Aside from the expected early game jitters and overexcitement, something did not quite look right with Newton. He appeared to be constantly out of breath and experiencing pain in his non-throwing shoulder. Did anyone else notice? the CBS crew certainly didn't.

* Petulant, petty, front-running Cam Newton re-emerged yesterday which is too bad. He could have handled the post-game press conference a little better, but if i'm a Panthers' fan I want my QB to be sullen and pissed off after a Super Bowl loss. At least you know he cares. And you know Josh Norman cares.

* John Elway's heavy bet to go all in after the Broncos' Super Bowl loss to the Seahawks and make a series of championship runs during the fast closing window of opportunity with Peyton Manning paid off. Sure, they'll be in salary cap hell for the next three years but at least they got the ring.

* Midway through the second half didn't it just feel like a regular Sunday night game? Or worse, a Thursday night game?

* Even without a fair catch, defenders have to give punt returners a bit of space to catch the ball which is why i don't understand why they didn't call a penalty on the Panther who touched Sanders right before he caught his big punt return.

* I must have read at least four long articles in the Times, ESPN, the Post, etc. on the specially grown and installed turf at Levi's Field. And yet all I heard during the game was how terrible the field and the footing was. How does that happen?

* Glad to see referee Clete Blakeman got the league memo on calling penalties on helmet to helmet hits no matter what you have to do. Denver's Malik Jackson hit helmet to helmet with Cam Newton. But since Newton was a runner he's not "defenseless" so that can't be called (i.e., the Ryan Shazier rule). Instead, he  got called for an unnecessary roughness "late hit." To be fair to Jackson, it was a bang bang play and Newton wasn't down when Jackson went to hit him and maybe not even when he did make contact. Still, the NFL doesn't want Nantz and Simms explaining a la the Steelers-Broncos game why helmet to helmet hits are still legal in today's NFL. We'll know when the NFL's neurologists and spotters are actually doing their job when they buzz down to take a look at Cam Newton after a hit to the head like he suffered. Until then, we'll all pretend the NFL is getting serious about head trauma.

* How reluctant was CBS to report that Philly Brown was out of the game with a concussion? Is it better to deliver news like that, or pretend that players like Julian Edelman don't have concussions and are continuing to play?

* is there any irony that Broncos owner Pat Bowlen is suffering from Alzheimer's?

A FIRST In School History


Sunday, February 07, 2016

Prediction

Panthers 41
Broncos 14

TO

On Super Bowl Sunday and in the wake of his falling short in the HOF balloting, it's worth remembering what Terrell Owens did in Super Bowl XXXIX.


At times, Owens was indeed disruptive, for various reasons. But did Owens really make his teams worse? He returned from a broken ankle to be arguably the best player on the field in Super Bowl XXXIX, and the Eagles lost that game to the Patriots not because of anything T.O. did but despite an effort that everyone who was paying attention recognized as heroic and memorable.
 
Only after the Eagles refused to acknowledge those contributions with a contract providing him greater compensation and protections did he decide to provoke a trade or release in 2005. Was it an ill-advised, selfish move? Yes, but it was compelled by a system that allows teams to rip up contracts when a player underperforms but prevents players from doing the same when they overdeliver.
 
A decade later, media and fans seem to better understand that, when players choose to act like owners, players shouldn't automatically be vilified the way Owens was.

First off, Owens was outstanding vs. the Patriots. He led the team in receptions (9) and yards (122). And he did it on a broken ankle.

But the behavior of Jeffrey Lurie and his management team may even be worse than what Florio blandly describes. There are rumors that TO asked to have his contract guaranteed before the game so that if he reinjured himself - playing as he was on a not fully healed broken ankle - he would be taken care of. Lurie et. al said no. TO played anyway, and played great. It was this refusal and the realization that TO's big numbered contract was actually not as lucrative nor as long as he thought  prompted him to try to renegotiate it after the Super Bowl.

I recall it being clear at the time that TO's contract was very team-friendly and a heap of abuse was dumped on TO for wanting to re-do a year after he signed it. Florio is right that fans are more savvy about player contracts than at that time and (slightly) more understanding of player efforts to renegotiate. Where TO lost the fans (and his teammates) was with the disruptive way he went about sabotaging the team on the field and in the locker room as a reprisal.

Rubio's Petard

There's a delicious irony in Marco Rubio getting pounded last night by Chris Christie over his "25 second memorization" critique of Rubios' super-scripted debate responses. The attack is a meta-critique of debate prep and process in the exact same way Rubio blasted Jeb Bush in a debate several months ago that criticized Bush not for the accusation he made but that his advisors told him to say it to score a political point. In both instances, the substance of the point isn't the issue but about how practiced and inauthentic the candidate really is. In the case of Rubio, it's a devastating line of attack since his biggest claim to fame during the campaign so far has been his supposed eloquence and ability to deliver a message - and not about the content of the message itself. That it was delivered by a governor against a senator is a bonus in that it reminds voters that Washington politicians (as opposed to state chief executives) talk a great deal but get very little gets done.

Props

Here are a number of interesting prop bets that I like for today's game

* Any total passing yards option for Manning that is under 200 yards total.

* Under 35.5 passes attempted by Manning.

* Over 1.5 interceptions

* Cam Newtown for MVP (-140)

* No missed PAT (-360)

* Under 34 yards for longest completion by Manning

* Broncos score in all 4 quarters (No -360)

Obviously I like the Panthers to win the game based on these picks.


Cool Fan Protest

I don't know the particulars of what the Liverpool fans are protesting with respect to new ticket prices or American ownership, but I'm very impressed that they were able to organize a sizeable number of fans to walkout during the 77th minute of the match. How cool would it be if American fans could or would do something with one of the professional sports teams.

Saturday, February 06, 2016

A Question and an Impossibility

Here's an interesting question that no one from the NFL or Broncos wants to talk about. How much and in which direction would the line move if the Gary Kubiak announced that Brock Osweiler was going to start tomorrow's Super Bowl instead of Peyton Manning? Currently the line is -5.5 for the Panthers. My guess is that it would move in the Broncos favor---at least a half point and maybe even a full point to -4.5. 

This all was prompted by the prop bet i heard about that was the over/under of the number of players who threw passes in the big game. The line is 2.5 passers and the over is +175. Now maybe this is all about whether Emmanuel Sanders or Mike Tolbert toss a pass on some trick play. But I was thinking of whether Osweiler would come in for a struggling Manning.

Here's the thing. Manning isn't coming out of tomorrow's game, no matter how dreadful he is. I fully understand it. On the biggest stage and in what could be the last game of his first ballot Hall of Fame career, Kubiak is going to stick with Manning no matter what. Even if that "what" is a struggling offense with no first downs, and 3 INTs before halftime. Unfortunately - and let's face it - that scenario is a definite possibility given Manning's history in the playoffs and especially in the Super Bowl.

All of which makes me think that while I think the Panthers will win, they could win very big. There may come a time during the game where the Broncos and Manning are struggling but the game is still within reach. I don't expect to see Osweiler even if it makes sense. Kubiak will continue to throw Manning out there and for that I think the game could get out of reach shortly afterward.

Josh Norman should take away the deep ball and with Manning's weak arm strength these days, the Panthers' elite set of LBs seem uniquely suited to stopping his short and intermediate throws.

Again, writing this gives me no pleasure. But it is the reality as Manning did not have a good year and is at the very tail end of his career. The Broncos D has carried this team most of the season (though Osweiler was 5-2 as the starter) and especially in the playoffs. Indeed, Manning only threw for 17 completions and 176 yards vs. the Patriots in the AFC Championship.

But it's sad to realize that for as great Manning has been, him not playing and a second round pick out of ASU named Brock Osweiler may give the Broncos a better chance of winning the pro championship.

Friday, February 05, 2016

Media's GOP Double Standard Bigotry Problem

It's easy enough for the media to lampoon Donald Trump as narrow-minded and mean-spirited for wanting to enforce immigration laws and to suspend Muslim migration from the Middle East to the US. But there's finally an article that highlights that these views aren't held just by Trump among current presidential contenders. The big problem according to Max Fisher is the media's double standard when it comes to reporting on Islamaphobia by Trump vs. the rest of the GOP field.

The key points:

But what is really striking to me about Rubio's comments is the media's reaction, which has been fairly muted in contrast to how it covered Islamophobic comments from Donald Trump. That's not to say that the media is endorsing or ignoring Rubio here, but the pretty clear distinction in coverage shows how an establishment candidate like Rubio can navigate the media's unwritten rules and get away with participating in the tide of Islamophobia that has already become violent.

He goes on to note:
What Rubio has revealed here, intentionally or not, is how a major political candidate can slip at least seemingly Islamophobic comments past the media without generating the same level of scrutiny and adversarial coverage that Trump has drawn...
This double standard became particularly transparent in December, when Trump praised Russian President Vladimir Putin. The media, again, heaped open scorn on Trump — how dare he praise a murderous dictator and American adversary? And, indeed, it was deplorable...
But mainstream political figures had been praising Putin for years, often in the very same language, and it never drew the same media condemnation. But the media treated those comments, though substantially identical, as acceptable.

It's what happened when South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley took issue with Trump's strident immigration stances (unnamed) while at the same time she was refusing to let Syrian refugees settle in her state and joined with 26 other states trying to over turn the Obama administration's immigration actions.

It's easy for the media to call out the prejudices of the marginalized, and much harder for those actually in power. Of course, it's just two institutional establishments winking and nodding at each other at the expense of the downtrodden.
 

Wednesday, February 03, 2016

The Walmart Strategy

The key paragraph from this Dallas Uber driver revolt story:


The experience of the Dallas UberBlack drivers is telling. When Uber entered Dallas in 2012, many of the drivers were either independent hired-car operators or contractors for limousine companies who bought or leased their own cars...
The drivers formed a tactical alliance with the company to help it gain the city's approval, which local cab operators resisted.
But the relationship began to sour in 2014, when the company decreed that drivers with cars made before 2008 would no longer be able to participate in UberBlack...
By the time Uber handed down its UberX directive in September, the drivers had long since recognized that they were at the company's beck and call. Because of Uber's popularity, almost all their other sources of business had dried up. And Uber had earned the imprimatur of the City Council, which made the drivers politically expendable, too.

So the story goes use non-cab drivers to champion your illegal/non-regulatory entry into a market with policymakers. In turn, the start up's success eliminates all of the competition. When Uber's pricing power is near monopolistic, it starts in on the former champions now current drivers - who have no recourse since all the no alternative options have been driven from the market.

It's a similar refrain to Walmart's low-cost producers. They are enticed into agreements with Walmart by the allure of massive selling volume. Walmart insists on razor thin margins for whatever product is being provided. In order to provide the sheer amount of product, a company foregoes all other customers and focuses exclusively on its Walmart account. As the sole customer, Walmart then insists on even lower prices, which the vendor has to accede to since they don't have any other customers and have increased investments in ever larger capacities.

The Snake and CTE

The news isn't surprising but it must be haunting to learn that Ken Stabler had stage 3 CTE. Stabler's status highlights some key lessons about football and brain trauma. The more you play, the more likely and more severe the damage. No position is immune from the scourge - even QBs. And the fact that they're finding it in players from the days of yore - before the speed, size and hits of the game truly amped up in the 90s and 00s - should be terrifying for the health prospects for players in that more recent era.

And I also wonder what Stabler's liver looked like!

Tuesday, February 02, 2016

What?

Two surprises from this interview:

1. Former Buckeye coach Jim Tressel is president of Youngstown State University?
2. Former Eagle Kurt Coleman paralyzed someone on the football field?

Monday, February 01, 2016

182

Here's some news that is very hard if not impossible to find on the NFL website. The number of concussions in the 2015 season.

PFT has the number at 182 - or more than 10 per week in the 17 week/16 game season. It's a stunning 32% increase over last year's number! And as an indication of the opaqueness of the NFL stats as well as the whole process of diagnosing and counting concussions, it's not clear whether Case Keenum's Nov. 22 head injury was included in the count. 

In fact, the NFL's Dr. Ellenbogen attributed to the spike in concussions to "lower threshold for diagnosis." The Keenum case would seem to directly contradict that statement and suggest that that the NFL and its hired medical personnel are still in denial about the extent and severity of its head trauma crisis.

It also would be interesting to see the numbers for the playoffs. Off the top of my head, there were 2 concussions in the Steelers-Bengals game (Bernard and Brown). How many others? 

Also, in a weird way the concussion count distracts attention from the more serious and much more prevalent problem of sub-concussive blows to the head that are a primary cause of CTE. In that respect, 182 should be considered a floor and not a celebratory ceiling.

Who Works for You?

"Enforcement isn't about big government or small government. It's about whether government works and who it works for." - Elizabeth Warren.

A Queen is Crowned?

Good grief. Not content to merely declare Megyn Kelly one of the winners of Thursday night's GOP presidential debate, the Washington Post now calls her "the start of the show."

What happened to the journalistic principles of not making the reporter or news organization part of the story, much less the centerpiece? Or is this a way to demean the rest of the Republican field who couldn't outshine the white, blonde, bombshell who was asking them questions? The focus on Kelly also has the fortunate side effect of brushing off uncomfortable questions about the appropriateness of Fox News' press releases mocking Donald Trump or exploring legitimate questions as to whether Fox moderators ask harder questions (or at least more incendiary) of certain candidates.

Maybe Megyn Kelly should throw her hat in the ring. She's got the full support of the national press.

Saturday, January 30, 2016

Ertz Extension

Since he came into the league three years ago, Eagles TE Zach Ertz seems to be more known for what he could be rather than what he is. So it is with the five year extension Howie Roseman signed him to this week that will make him one of the highest-paid TEs in the league.

Certainly, by most stats Ertz is in the top quarter of TEs. This past season he was 6th in catches, 7th in yards, and 7th in yards/game. But with 3 less catches, he would have dropped to 9th in that category and he only scored two TDs, ranking him 33rd! among his peers.

Ertz is a decent TE. But he is hardly an elite TE. Indeed, he's perhaps only the 3rd best TE in the division (behind Witten and Reed). The deal is fair - $20 million guaranteed! - and gives the Eagles some outs in the later years. But until he starts producing like a premier TE, let's not project what Ertz could do as the basis for measuring him, but what he has actually done.