Play Calling

Sam Donnellon with a wonderful turn of phrase to describe Andy Reid's play calling: "A disciple of the system that made a household name of the late Bill Walsh, Reid has proved to be the equivalent of a student who studies hard but does not always test well. Or a pianist who can interpret the masters beautifully but can't write a lick of music himself."

It's important to remember that Reid was never an offensive coordinator before he became the Eagles head coach. He's a terrific head coach in keeping the team cohesive and focused. But as a play calling coach - not so much. That's why giving Marty Mohrninweg the playcalling authority was so important to many fans. Alas, his meddling continues to plague the offense.

And it is so telling that nine years after his arrival, with a franchise QB, and Reid's "offensive philosophy," that it is Jim Johnson's defense that has historically and continues to this day to be the best part of the Eagles squad.