Monday, September 17, 2007

Must Win?

While I agree that tonight’s Eagles game is a big one, I’m not so sure, as Ashley Fox asserts, that “this one will determine a season. This one will decide success or failure.” Whoa. Easy.

 

Starting off 0-2 would be bad, don’t get me wrong. And yes, the Eagles’ started off 0-2 in 2003 and still got to the NFC Championship, but this team, this division, and this conference are vastly different than four years ago. But I don’t think the fate of the season rides on tonight’s game. I think it will certainly have playoff implications down the road were they to start 0-2, especially two losses to conference opponents and one in division. Of course, the Eagles wouldn’t have the pressure on them that they do if they hadn’t squandered the victory in Green Bay.

 

And as I wrote earlier this week, 0-2 would put them 2 games back two games into the season (!) to division rivals Dallas and 2 ½ games back of Washington, As concerned I would be about 0-2, I would also worry about the momentum the Redskins pick up from a win and the possibility of going 3-0 vs. the hapless Giants next week.

 

Still, if we’ve learned anything in recent years, particularly last season, is that the NFL season is an incredibly long journey filled with more twists and turns and developments and subplots than All My Children. 0-2 would be bad, but not the end of the world.

Jeff Lurie= Dan Snyder?

Jeff Lurie is doing his best Dan Snyder impersonation with the Eagles’ new parking/tailgate rules.  Snyder, of course, is the Redskins owner who presides over the most cockamamie stadium parking lot in the NFL -  with limited spaces, color-coded sections requiring specific permits, and cash lots so far away that fans have to take shuttles to FedEx Field.

 

As the Daily News reports, “The Eagles have decreed that tailgaters may no longer set up tables or tents or pay to reserve the space next to their cars. If you want to tailgate, you now have to do it behind your car, standing in the parking-lot lanes where other fans are driving by. Some fun. On top of all that, the Eagles increased the price from $11 to $20 for cars and from $20 to $40 for RVs to park in one of those lots.”

 

As an Eagles fan who tailgates with a group of buddies in an RV and pays for an extra adjoining parking space to set up our grills, tables, chairs, and Beirut table, I will tell you that that this new rule has the potential to backfire. Big Time. I understand the imperative to increase the traffic flow into the lots. But forcing tailgaters to all congregate in the lanes means that it will be more difficult for cars to navigate the lots and thus backup traffic – in the parking lots themselves and eventually spilling out onto the street. And that doesn’t even take into account the very questionable safety of such a system. Pedestrians + roughhousing + game playing + alcohol + cars = a deadly mix. And the Eagles are penalizing fans willing to pay for what they use – in some cases two parking spots – rather than own up to their own inadequacy in providing sufficient parking around the stadium.

 

I think I speak for many fans when I suggest that Jeff Lurie and the Eagles concern themselves more with the disastrous egress of fans and cars AFTER games rather than before them. It is inexplicable that a stadium located at the locus of so many major highways continues to have gridlocked traffic two to three hours after the game has ended.

 

As one friend told me, the Eagles really need to watch themselves. They are flush and full right now, but things can change. Indeed. It was less than ten years ago that Veterans Stadium was not sold out and season tickets were easily available. Donovan McNabb fixed that. But as we are all aware, McNabb won’t play forever. Can Kevin Kolb similarly fill seats and the win column? We shall see.

Friday, September 14, 2007

Placeholder Solution

My friend PK’s solution to the Eagles’ placeholder issues: “Do what the Cowboys used to do and put a backup tight end there. Or even a backup running back. Anyone who has great hands and can simply call out f-ing snap count signals. When he was a backup, I think Jay Novacek used to hold for Jimmy Johnson. Smart guy, sure hands. “

Not a bad idea. Greg Lewis, Matt Schobel, hey, why not get maximum value out of Reno Mahe and put him back there to placehold too.

Worse than First Appears

All reports I’ve seen regarding the Patriots’ spying only report of a man taping the Jets’ signals from the Patriots’ side of the field. But does Sheldon Brown break news today about the Patriots’ spying that went beyond the videos?

 

“’"Not only did they have a guy on the field with a camera,’' Brown said. ‘But they had a guy on the Jets sidelines? Come on,’” he says in today’s Inquirer. What guy on the Jets’ sideline?

WHITE WASH

My friends’ verdict:

 

Belichick gets a $500k fine himself, the organization gets another $250k fine, no suspension for Coach Hoody Sweatshirt. They lose a 1st rounder if they make the playoffs this year, if not, a 2nd and 3rd rounder.

 

What's not fair in all this is that the "investigation" is now over. The greatest team of the decade with the biggest star in the league, both accused of cheating, ADMITTING they cheated, and there's no broader investigation into how often the Pats did this, how much of an assistance it was to them, etc. WHITE WASH!


This penalty looks stiff on its face, but mort is saying they still have another first round pick next year (from a trade with the niners), so this won't affect them much, not to mention the likelihood that this will be a pick in the high 20's.  Apparently there's a whole list of cheating allegations.  SI reports teams' radios going out at key plays of their offensive drives, and further suspicions that pats' interior linemen were wired to pick up opposing qb's audible system.  there's a ton of stuff out there, I'm sure exaggerated, but very possibly true.  Let's hope goodell continues to dig. To not fully investigate-and for owners not to demand an investigation-is a bad job.  Looks like the most we can hope for is 1)this ruling causes them to curb some of their cheating, making a more level playing field for honest teams, and 2)their reputation will be tarnished.

Slap on Belichick's Wrist

The NFL “punishment” imposed on Bill Belichick for cheating is a $500,000 fine and the loss of one, or two, low draft picks. What a joke. The NFL is trying to sell it as the same tough stance on management as players. “Roger Goodell's hard line on discipline, aimed so far at players, came down this time on a coach and a team,” says the NFL website.

 

The $500,000 is only 12.5% of Belichick’s annual $4 million salary. It’s not going to hurt him too much in the wallet. And the conditional draft picks sanction is downright bizarre. It means that the NFL didn’t want them to lose a draft pick any lower than the mid-20’s. And the fact that they still have the Niners #1 pick even if they have to forfeit their own means the net effect of the punishment is negligible. Either they will have two #1s or a #1, #2, and #3 in the upcoming draft. Goodell considers that a punishment?  Indeed, from a salary cap standpoint, the Patriots could actually benefit from losing their #2 and #3 since they will have to pay big money to sign two #1s. I doubt they would have the cap room to sign two #1s, and a #2, and a #3 – to say nothing of their picks in rounds 4-7.

 

What’s not clear is whether the fines were for the single incident involving the Jets or a larger conspiracy to cheat other teams/games. What is clear is that when push came to shove, Goodell didn’t have the balls to suspend Belichick and go against owner Robert Kraft. I can only assume from this ridiculous “investigation” (how neat and tidy that it was all completed in less than a week) and “punishment” is that the NFL must be concerned about this spying occurring in some of the Patriots’ high profile games (i.e., Super Bowls) and doesn’t want to look too closely into it lest it find disturbing evidence that would only further taint the Patriots’ three championships.

 

 

 

 

Patriots Spy-Gate

Steelers WR Hines Ward “is certain the Patriots, while known for the thoroughness of their scouting under coach Bill Belichick, had some kind of unusual help before their 24-17 upset victory in Pittsburgh in the January 2002 AFC championship game. The Patriots went on to win the first of their three Super Bowls.

‘Oh, they knew,’ Ward said Wednesday. ‘They were calling our stuff out. They knew, especially that first championship game here at Heinz Field. They knew a lot of our calls. There's no question some of their players were calling out some of our stuff,’” reports SI.

 

Ok, here’s my question. Why didn’t Goodell call in any of the Patriots current or former players to ask what they knew about all this? At some point for the spying to be of any benefit it has to be translated to the players on the field. Ask them how it is they knew exactly what plays the opposition would run.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

Blitz Screen

In light of the Patriots Spy Games Scandal, it's interesting to read this Boston Globe account of the Eagles-Patriots Super Bowl and the "adjustments" the Pats' offense made to counter the Eagles' blitzes. Was this good play-calling, or did Charlie Weis and Tom Brady know what defense the Eagles would be in and when they were blitzing cause they had taped Jim Johnson's defensive play calls. Even more interesting, the story notes that through the first and much of the second quarter, the Eagles defense had rattled Brady and the Patriots. And then? All of the sudden the Pats' offense regained its composure was able to handle the Eagles' blitzes for the rest of the game. Almost like they deciphered the Eagles' defensive schemes...or calls.

The NFL and Goodell need to realize that this Patriot Spy Scandal is bigger than just a regular season game against the Jets. They need to start looking at a lot more of the Patriots' games. They can start with the Super Bowls. And Goodell can interview Charlie Weis and Romeo Crennell about what they know about the use of cameras on the Patriots' sideline to tape opposing teams' signals.


Excerpts from the story:

"Any time you blitz a lot, you start to think you're running free at the quarterback," Brady said. "We got some good yardage with those screens because they thought the scheme got them free on those plays. When we gashed them, it helped slow them down."

"After adjusting their defensive game plan, Brady had just enough breathing room to begin the steady process of dissecting the Eagles' defense and destroying their Super Bowl dreams."

"On the first drive of the second half, the Eagles tried to go back to their blitz but Branch destroyed the Eagles, catching four passes for 71 yards. One reception beat the Eagles' blitz for a 27-yard gain and another did the same for a 21-yard catch that put the ball on the 2-yard line."

"Although Philadelphia blitzed more later in the game, the Eagles never returned to the all-out attack they had been using."

Calling NFL Films

Quick, get Steve Sabol on the phone and have his crack NFL Films staff
start poring over the Patriots' Super Bowl games. Start with the
Eagles. There are so many cameras at these events that surely some
would have plenty of sideline footage to reveal if the Pats were
videotaping the Eagles' signals...and the Rams, and the Panthers......

Goodell's Half-Baked "Investigation"

Per PK's earlier criticism of the media' inattention to the THE story of the 2007 NFL season so far, why hasn't commish Roger Goodell called in other Patriots to inquire about the Pats' use of videotaped opposition signals?

The issue at hand goes beyond actually taping the signals, but what the Patriots -- coaches and players -- then did with those signals. Why isn't Goodell interviewing Corey Dillon, Kevin Faulk, Troy Brown, Dan Koppen, Tom Ashworth, Tedy Bruschi, Rodney Harrison (currently serving a four game suspension for cheating with HGH), Richard Seymour, Ted Johnson, Willie McGinest, Lawyer Milloy, and...material witness #1 - Tom Bradyetc? Get them on the record about their first-hand knowledge of the videotaped signals and if they were used to gain a competitive advantage in/during games.

The fact that Goodell hasn't formally spoken to players - and the noise emanating from league offices that the commissioner will take away draft picks as a show of "toughness" (and not suspend Belichick) - suggests a white wash in the works to protect Belichick, Kraft, and
the Pats.

Where's the Scandal? In the Media

My friend PK is a reporter for a national media company. His take on
the Bill Belichick scandal, or non-scandal, in the news world so far:

This scandal is HUGE and not being given nearly enough coverage. And I
mean from the national media writ large, not the stupid shucksters on
espn and the "best damn sports show".

The National Football League is The Sport of America, 13 times more
popular than any other league. The Preeminent Coach of the National
Football League - with the Preeminent QB of the National Football
League as the main beneficiary - have now been formally caught
illegally videotaping defensive signals for the benefit of Tom Brady.

Am I missing something??????

If accurate, would this not be the '50s equivalent of learning the
Yankees stole most signals for DiMaggio's plate appearances, then
Mantle's? The fact that Bobby Thomson's Shot Heard Round the World was
from a stolen sign now dramatically changes our view of things, but we
didn't learn it until 45 yrs or so after the homer.

Ok, Eagles fans. Anyone remember how thoroughly we dominated the Pats
in the 1st Q of that Super Bowl. What turned things around?

Two BACK-to-BACK screen passes by Brady to Dillon or Faulk in the Pats
1st drive of 2ndQ!!!! I remember clear as day the Inside the NFL guys
flipping out over the back-to-back screen calls by the "genius" Pats
coordinators. I swear one of them - or maybe Harry the K - said
something like, They called those plays like they knew the defense the
Eagles were running on those plays!

HELLO!

That's what this scandal does, or should do. Rock to the core the very
fabric of the Patriots.

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

Patriot-gate

Besides filming the opposing team's signals, the incident in NY this past weekend also involved funny business with the teams' radio frequencies. What could that be about? PFT reports of "suspicions/rumors regarding efforts by the Pats to get a leg up as to opposing offenses. Specifically, we're told that it's believed that, during the 2006 season, the Patriots were putting microphones on defensive linemen in order to capture the offensive line calls and the quarterback audibles. Then, the audio and the video of the game would be matched up, and the defensive players would be given the code at halftime."

But here's where it gets really weird. You probably noticed the green dot/sticker on the back of the QB's helmet this weekend or during the preseason. The dot indicates to the ref that the helmet is outfitted with a radio receiver so the QB can receive the play from the sideline. Each team is only allowed one "green dot" helmet on the field at any one time. My friend explained that it was his understanding that some team (the Falcons?) did at least one trick play last year where they brought in Matt Schaub at QB and split Vick out wide or in the backfield and the Falcons gained some sort of advantage by having two players able to listen to the Offensive Coodinator prior to the play.

But this new green dot rule raises some interesting questions in light of the burgeoning Patriots scandal. Why did the league institute the "green dot" rule? Was it really for the incident/scenario mentioned above? Or did the league have an inkling that some team (did they suspect the Patriots) was monkeying around with the helmet radio receivers for a more pronounced/blatant advantage? If the ongoing NFL investigation uncovers evidence of the Patriots secretly violating the green dot rule, will that be cause to increase the punishment imposed by the league?

Stay tuned.

Patriot Games

The Mike Vick case was a no brainer challenge to new NFL Commish Roger Goodell. Dog fighting? Canine-cide? Gambling? Federal prison? Suspending Vick was practically a foregone conclusion for Goodell.

But Patriot-gate is a whole other ballgame. Will Goodell have the balls to suspend the great Bill Belichick for his team's filming of opposing team signals? As Pro Football Talk pointed out, " If punter Todd Sauerbrun gets tossed for four games for using ephedra...[and] Cowboys quarterbacks coach Wade Wilson gets parked for five games because he purchased HGH for his own personal use, the head coach of a team that is committing a blatant violation of the rules for competitive advantage should be suspended much longer than that."

At the least, Goodell will strip the team of a couple of draft picks, though really, in the scheme of things, that is a slap on the wrist. But suspend Belichick? Bob Kraft's man? We'll see if Goodell has the cojones.

Gambling on Reno

Reno Mahe is set to return: punts and to the Eagles. I wonder if he feels vindicated? Is he aware that he was such a lightning rod for criticism in his last two years on the team? Fans inexplicably vilified Mahe for doing nothing particularly well. A jack of all trades, master of none type deal. The very definition of a journeyman professional football player.

But what we've come to appreciate about Mahe in the past week that we failed to take into account over the past couple of years is the one thing it turns out he did do particularly well. Catch punts and hold onto the ball.

Of course, Mahe's return is just the latest evidence that Andy Reid, Tom Heckert, and Rory Segrest are in deep doo doo as far as special teams is concerned. Sure Mahe is a known commodity with Big Red. But the fact remains that Reid's "solution" to the sudden crisis in the kick/punt return game - a crisis of his own making over the past three weeks - is to turn to a player who was completely out of football. Did I miss something or did Mahe not try out in any team's camp this summer?

Let's hope he's in shape, but really who cares. He's going to be on the field for 7-8 plays - none of them consecutive (knock on wood, I just guaranteed an offside kickoff and/or punt penalties requiring re-kicks) - and he doesn't even have to exert himself after the catch. Heck, fans would be thrilled with 5 uneventful fair catches. In theory, its so easy Brian Westbrook could have done that (and not risked getting injured). Unfortunately, it's not something G. Lew or JR Reed could do.

The larger issue is that he hasn't participated in a professional football activity, practice, etc. for at least 9 months. Reid is going to rely on a punt returner after only five days of practice? Even G. Lew had more reps than that.

Is this about Reid's comfort level with Mahe? Is it that Reid's ego won't let him admit the mistake of letting Jeremy Bloom go, so they can't go out and ask him to come back? Or is this just a coach grasping at straws - anything, even if it is Reno Mahe - to help bail him out of the hole he has dug for himself and his team? Methinks the last choice.

Seriously. Reno Mahe?  Eric Metcalf or Roy Green weren't available?

Welcome back Reno. No hard feelings. Good luck

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

Our Own Mascot?

Interesting anthropological look at the curious specimen: “Eagles fan.”

 

“The Phillies may boast the Phanatic, but Eagles fans are their own greatest mascots.”

How Low Can You Go?

Eagles special teams, so competent and so influential in seasons past (see: Westbrook, Brian, punt return vs. Giants, or Sand Diego, Field Goal blocked…touchdown), has sunk to this. As USA Today neatly captures the it: “Wanted: punt returner. Requirements: catch the ball. The Philadelphia Eagles don't need a return specialist with game-breaking skills. They just need someone who knows when to call a fair catch or when to simply let the ball bounce.”

It’s so bad the Eagles aren’t even worrying about how many return yards they can get, they just want someone who can catch the ball. Jeez, by that standard Jeremy Bloom or, dare we say Reno Mahe, are looking pretty good right now.

What a mess.

Monday, September 10, 2007

Red(skin) Alert!

As if the Redskins-Eagles game wasn't enough of a must-win for the Eagles or face falling two games behind in the NFC East race to the Redskins, it now appears that the Redskins stand to benefit the most from Eli Manning's separated shoulder and that it is very possibly the Eagles are the only thing that stand in the way of the Redskins starting  6-0.

The Redskins play the Giants at home following their game with the Eagles. They then have their bye, play Detroit at home, go to Green Bay, are home against Arizona and then go to New England. After the Eagles, they will likely be favored in every game up to New England. This is a very dangerous development. The Redskins are going to be a competitive rival this year and the one thing you don't want to do is allow that squad to get on a roll and have them start believing in Joe Gibbs and his system. They have a young quarterback and it's imperative to not give him confidence and a comfort zone. Plus, they could be 2-0 in the division three weeks into the season if they beat the Eagles.

Even before the news out of NY, this was going to be a big game for the Eagles: losing the opener (and in the fashion they did), a game vs. a division rival, and, oh yeah, at home. But with the injury to Eli Manning (taking the last hope out of the Giants for the rest of the season, they are finito) the Redskins are primed to make a run against some now very questionable competition, and this game on Monday night has taken on even more importance than before.

Cheatin' Bill Belicheck?

The Jets-Pats feud, or is it the Mangini-Belicheck fight, just gets more intense…and strange.

 

“NFL security confiscated a video camera and its tape from a New England Patriots employee on the team's sideline during Sunday's game against the Jets in a suspected spying incident, sources said….The Patriots' cameraman was suspected of aiming his camera at the Jets' defensive coaches who were sending signals to their unit on the field, the sources said. The league also is investigating some radio frequency issues that occurred during the game,” reports ESPN’s Chris Mortensen. sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=3012989&campaign=rss&source=ESPNHeadlines

Game in Review

You know it’s a bad game or a bad loss when the most positive thing you can take away from it is that Lito Sheppard might only miss the next game.

 

Criminy.  This loss is such a gut punch cause it was such a winnable game. There was a period watching the NFL ticket yesterday where we were switching back and forth from the Eagles as the Pack was running clock before their field goal and the Redskins were lining up for their game winner in OT. In the span of, literally, a minute and a half the Eagles suffered a two game swing in the division, going down 0-1 while the Skins got to 1-0.

 

This one could come back to haunt them when it comes to seedings and byes (if we get that far). I take some solace in that Reid has been very mediocre in openers (3-5). And the Inqy points out today that Reid’s team has made the championship game in three years where they lost the opener, but not sure if that counts “blowing” the opener.

 

Sadly, this was so predictable. Many of us saw the problem immediately after they cut Jeremy Bloom – who it now appears more than ever was a fall guy for the incompetence of new special teams coach Rory Segrest. You can’t pin what happened yesterday on Bloom. He might not have tallied a lot of return yards this preseason, but at least he held onto the ball. You can pin it on a coach who simply did not have his charges ready to play. Beyond the two disastrous Lewis and Reed “muffs” or fumbles, or whatever you want to call them, there was Lewis inexplicably diving for another bouncing punt, and getting in Reed’s way on ANOTHER punt. What a disaster. (PS – I understand what Reed was trying to do on that last punt. The Packer shanked it and Reed was trying to catch it to save field position. But he had to run so far and dive for it that I can’t believe he never thought about just letting it go. Or since he has been a kickoff return specialist, did he have a brain fart and think the ball had to be handled lest the Pack “recover the onside punt?”

 

Even us nonprofessional football people couldn’t believe that Greg Stinkin Lewis was the backup plan after they cut Jeremy Bloom. Lewis? Really? The guy had never fielded a punt in an NFL game. Coaches give such lip service to the importance of special teams. And the Eagles special teams have been very good under Reid because of David Akers and John Harbaugh. But yesterday had to call into question the larger issue of Reid’s priorities. Beyond Lewis returning punts, there is the issue of Akers’ holder. Clearly this is an important issue for our pro bowl kicker. Yet, Reid continues to insist that the punter hold. And now we’ve got an Australian punter whose never handled an American football before holding for #2. Somehow Dirk Johnson’s problems holding for Akers last year – replacing Koy Detmer - were dismissed as kicker eccentricity. The larger question is why our #2 QB, AJ Feeley, isn’t holding for Akers? (though a moot point now that Feeley has a broken hand). Why isn’t the QB the holder rather than the punter? This is crazy.

 

Here’s another point. If the Eagles bring in a returner, then they will have to open up a roster spot to make room for him. Who gets cut to open up a space?

 

Other thoughts and observations:

 

·         The defense played well, especially stopping the run. But let’s face it, the Packers don’t really have a running game.

·         McNabb may have looked rusty, but the line looked even worse. What happened to Todd Herremans? He was abused all game.

·         Has anyone seen Reggie Brown? Our supposed #1 receiver was AWOL.

·         A ton of penalties. And that doesn’t count all the ones that were declined. Terrible, sloppy, lazy, undisciplined.

·         Counting on Westbrook to carry more of the offensive load is understandable, but game plans like yesterday are crazy. Westbrook carried 20 times and had 6 catches. He must have also been thrown to 4 more times. That’s waaaay too much. To unbalanced. Too disproportionate. Too much of a load. If Bucky can’t adequately spell him and other guys can’t get into the offense then something drastic needs to be done or the Eagles need to reevaluate their talent evaluation.

Fool Me Twice, Shame on Me

“Segrest seemed to think the Birds would try to work with Lewis and Reed, rather than looking elsewhere for punt-return help. Obviously, the Eagles can always risk Brian Westbrook back there, if they have to,” reports the Inqy. What the ?!?@@#?$?%

Beginning of the End to the Reid Era?

Maybe, maybe not. But that’s what my angry friend writes me today after yesterday's debacle of a loss. At the very least, the veneer Reid enjoyed of being a very competent coach and detail-oriented guy has been stripped away after the special teams fiasco. . Indeed, Rich Hoffman makes that very point today, writing " But this has become one of the season's themes, this suddenly comfortable embrace of the high wire. You see it in big ways and small. They went with Sav Rocca, the inexperienced punter with all of the potential, over safe incumbent Dirk Johnson. They brought in another inexperienced backup linebacker, Pago Togafau, rather than a just-in-case veteran when they were doing their final roster-making. And they went with Greg Lewis and J.R. Reed to catch punts in the season opener at Green Bay."

 

Anyway, my angry fried PK writes: My prediction is simple: after all the offseason talk about No 5 and how long he'd be an Eagle, I'm flatly predicting that Donovan will last far longer in the Jeffrey Lurie organization than Andy Reid.

 

Today was the beginning of the end for Andy. It's gonna be a long 7-9 season, and all the weaknesses that Andy simply declined to address in the offseason will be key in their losses, their big losses. (Today: the kick return game, next week: probably a holder on FGs.)

 

The storyline is going to build that Reid was too distracted in the offseason (and preseason) by his children's drug habits to even handle player personnel situations, and he'll eventually resign in a Vermiel-style burnout press conference talking about his kids and the need to be a family man again.

 

This will politely overlook the fact that Andy has almost every offseason ignored some glaring holes in the organization (how many Super Bowls would we have gone to earlier this decade with just average wide receivers rather than the piss-poor shit we had on the field, how would the team have fared differently in '04-'06 if Reid had forced Johnson into getting bigger and tougher against the run on D?).

 

Sadly, the Reid Era began its final descent today, I believe.

 

Succint Summary of Eagles' Special Teams problems

THE NUT GRAF from the entire Philly sports coverage of yesterday’s Eagles’ loss:

 

From Les Bowen (who must really be disgusted cause his article mockingly shreds the Eagles’ brain trust and special teams coach):

 

“It took a couple of exhibition games to figure out Jeremy Bloom wasn't what they'd hoped for as a punt returner, after he'd looked great in practice. (Bloom did, in fact, catch cleanly every ball he went for, and might have been cut a little more slack, having not really played in 3 years.) They oriented everything toward giving Bloom optimal game reps early, didn't establish a primary backup, then didn't have time to adequately train a replacement when they cut him.”

Coach Muff

Who’s the genius who hired this genius?

 

“Any time you're on the receiving end of a kick, you definitely want to retain possession of the ball there,” Rory Segrest, current Eagles Special Teams coach.

Saturday, September 08, 2007

10-6?

For the first time since Doug Pederson was taking snaps under center, I do not have a good feeling about this Eagles team or season. Perhaps that is a good thing, as the Eagles have fallen short of my (and many others’) preseason expectations for eight straight years now. Even during TO’s second year implosion, I held out hope right up the point where the Eagles blew the home game versus the Cowboys and McNabb aggravated his sports hernia trying to tackle Roy Williams. Game. Set. Match.

I hope I am wrong but in four months, when the post-mortem is done on the season just completed, I fear that we’ll have a collective, “D’oh,” as the gift of hindsight makes this team’s deep flaws even more glaring. “The holes were there all along,” we’ll say, “we just didn’t want to see them or admit it.”

It now appears that the shifting balance of power from defense to offense is complete. For most of Andy Reid’s tenure the defense has carried this team. It was an irony never fully explored that a coach with an offensive pedigree and franchise QB could be the poor sister of Jim Johnson and his merry blitzing men: Hugh Douglas, Trot, Carlos Emmons B. Dawk, Corey Simon, Bobby Taylor, Troy Vincent.

This could be the year the Eagles inability to competently evaluate linebacker talent over the past decade and to groom a replacement to Brian Dawkins (buh-bye Norman LeJeune and CJ Gaddis) finally catches up with the team. Jim Johnson is a master defensive tactician and strategist, and you won’t here any complaints from him, but one has to wonder how getting smaller and less experienced at linebacker this year is going to help stop them from getting run over like they did last year (then again, the Colts’ won the Super Bowl with the worst run defense (5.5 yards/carry) of any team since 1972.)

The defensive ends are still light (in researching recent Eagle drafts I came across a short blurb on Trent Cole that had him projected as an outside LB in the NFL) and their highest-profile player, Jevon Kearse, is coming off a very significant knee injury. Sure they have more depth and size at defensive tackle – veteran run stuffers like Kimo van Oelfen and Montae Reagor, but in two years Mike Patterson has yet to show an ability to push the middle of the pocket. Then again, if Brodrick Bunkley plays the rampaging bull everyone thinks he can be, he’ll make them all look better.

Unfortunately, I can’t get the picture out of my mind of Omar Gaither being physically dominated by the Steelers offensive line during their 3rd preseason game. For the life of me, I can’t figure out why they cut Trotter. Were they really afraid such a stand up guy would be a problem being a leader if he was 2nd string? Wouldn’t having him as insurance have been worth the risk?

Gocong can’t be any worse than Dhani Jones last year but you have to accept a steep learning curve. If he picks things up half as fast as Gaither did last year, it will be a good deal. Backing both these guys up is another young guy, rookie Stewart Bradley. Though I have to think that if Gaither keeps getting pushed around the first option would be to move him back to weakside LB and put Takeo Spikes in the middle. Not sure how TKO would feel about that, but they cut the Trotter plan B option.

Lito Sheppard continues to raise his game. Funny to think he got the most crap of that class of defensive backs drafted in 2002 cause he was the last one to earn a starting spot, but he’s turned out to be the best. Sheldon Brown is a big hitter but has been exposed as an average cover corner without the help of a pass rush. #20 is the ageless wonder, and Sean Considine is going to be a whipping boy till he lays a real hard lick on someone. He’s my candidate for this year’s Matt McCoy award given annually to the white defensive player who becomes the fall guy for the defenses shortcomings.

Anyway, it’s a front-running defense. If they can play with a lead, and the offense should be able to score points, then maybe they won’t be abused or worn down.

Some NFL “experts” still think Donovan McNabb is a running QB and thus express concern about his knee recovery. He’ll be fine as long as Marty M. continues to call the plays, which a small blurb in the Philly Inquirer confirmed this weekend (funny how perhaps the most important news about the Eagles’ offense got so little coverage).

Everyone’s counting on Westbrook carrying a full load like he did during the Garcia games last year, but I am a little skeptical/worried about that. That was only 7 games last year – at the end of the season no less. Can you really ask Westbrook to carry 25 times (plus 6 catches) a game for 16 weeks? Uh, no. Fortunately, we won’t have to see Westbrook plunge into the line on 3rd and short (or a McNabb QB sneak) now that Tony Hunt is available. Fantasy alert: Hunt could be the Eagles’ version of “TD specialist” Brandon Jacobs this year.

Reggie Brown has a lot of expectations. We’ll see. This could be a breakout year for him. Or we could confirm that he is just a solid #2 WR. Somehow Greg Lewis is the new Reno Mahe. Not sure how he stays on the team, but he manages to make the roster and get on the field for significant playing time. Fielding punts, though? Yikes. Now that JR Reed is back on the team it will be interesting to see if the return problems were Jeremy Bloom’s (given his collegiate accomplishments I say no) or the new special teams coach Rory Segrest. Segrest has big shoes to fill, but it looks to me like Bloom was the fall guy while Segrest got acclimated to game action.

The O-line is solid once again. It is the one area that Reid has done his best personnel work. Thomas and Runyan are solid veterans, Herremans is serviceable, Jackson never missed a beat in replacing Honey Buns (might even be better), and Shawn “Big Kid” Andrews is a future Hall of Famer. If…..If the ankle injury isn’t as serious as he initially made it out to be. Supposedly his despondence in discussing the potentially career-threatening condition was an “act.” We’ll see. But it’s par for the course with the Eagles. It wouldn’t be an Andy Reid Eagles team without some concerns, controversies, secrecy and drama.

They probably go 10-6, maybe 11-5. Probably not enough to earn a bye, so here’s hoping that they can rest their starters in the Buffalo game. The key is to make the playoffs. Once there, anything can happen - just ask the Steelers, whose playoff run included knocking an all-pro QB out of the game, enduring a fumble on the goal line, a game saving tackle, a botched FG by the NFL's most accurate kicker, and the worst officiated Super Bowl in history. You just have to be in it to win it.

As for the rest of the division. The jury is still out on Tony Romo, but unfortunately he’s still got a bipolar diva in TO who will be causing problems by game 5 and a buffoon of a head coach in Wade Phillips who might make Dave Campo look like a genius. 8-8 for the ‘Boys?

The Giants are on a downward slide. They should have jettisoned the martinet Coughlin last year. Brandon Jacobs is no Tiki Barber, but he may on occasion look like Earl Campbell as he drags Omar Gaither ten yards. Eli Manning remains an enigma. If he doesn’t have a breakout year this season (and this is the third straight “ultimatum” for Manning) then the Giants’ long-term prospects look even bleaker. 7-9

The Redskins are the wild card. They could easily finish 11-5 or 5-11. They still don’t have a pass rush, OLB Marcus Washington is breaking down, and the rest of the LBs are young. But they’ve got two ferocious hitters at safety who can do lots of damage lots of different ways. On offense, Portis will share the load with Ladell Betts, though Portis is playing with a huge chip on his shoulder. It will be interesting to see if Jason Campbell can continue to improve. A Joe Gibbs offense wouldn’t ask him to do too much. Of course, this is a Al Saunders offense now so we’ll see.

The first two weeks will be key for the Eagles. The Pack have enough talent to contend for a weak North division title. And they could deal a heavy blow to a division rival with a win in week 2, especially if the Dolphins can beat them in the opener.

Friday, September 07, 2007

defining McNabb article?

A phenomenal article on Donovan McNabb and the issues, cross-currents, and controversies surrounding his star-crossed career with the Eagles.

 

The nut graphs: “Despite being one of the league's most successful signal-callers over the last eight years, he's also become arguably the most consistent lightning-rod athlete in the NFL since the turn of the millennium…

 

In fact, McNabb's success has been almost unparalleled since he entered the league. He's been far and away the jewel of the 1999 quarterback class, a group that included five first-round picks: McNabb, Tim Couch, Akili Smith, Cade McNown and Daunte Culpepper. Beyond McNabb and the roller-coaster career of Culpepper, it's a group marked by utter failure.”

 

His Right Leg?

#5’s comeback could determine the NFC championship race says this Minneapolis Tribune article.

 

 

Thursday, September 06, 2007

Owner's Stooge


Is there a more toadyish union leader in today's world than NFLPA executive director Gene Upshaw? We think not. Upshaw has come under increasing scrutiny and criticism for the way his association's retirement and disability plans treat former NFL players. It's gotten so bad that he's now hired a PR firm and crisis management guru Lanny Davis to help implement a charm offensive. Thus, this front Sports page profile of Upshaw and the controversies in the Washington Post.

Bottomline: Forget about the retired player, though their treatment is an absolute disgrace. Upshaw has been positively negligent in running the NFLPA for the current players.
The NFL is the premier sports league, by far, in the United States. Yet, somehow the best players - like Peyton Manning or Donovan McNabb - at the most important position on the field do not make as much in annual salary ($10 million and $5.5 million respectively) as journeyman pitchers like Gil Meche, a career 62-56 pitcher who the Royals will pay an average of $11 million per year over the next five years! Maybe Jon Kitna is the NFL's version of Gil Meche, but Kitna will only make $5 million this year, less than half of Meche's take.

Wednesday, September 05, 2007

Waaaa

Chipper Jones isn’t chipper about the umpiring in yesterday’s Phillies game.

 

"The first pitch to me with the bases loaded was in my batter's box, inside. Now you tell me how I'm supposed to hit that. We have to get Questec here in this ballpark. We've got to. Umpires have got to be held accountable. That's Little League World Series stuff right there. It's a joke. I'm tired of it. And baseball can fine me whatever they want," said Jones

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

Big Kid Kidding Around

Our future Hall of Fame guard, the Big Kid, now says that he was just messin with the media and that his ankle injury was never career threatening but he wanted to see their reaction. Ha ha ha.

Not funny, Shawn. It's not everyday your favorite football team drafts a future Hall of Fame lineman. A lineman whose career might have been cut short by fluke ankle injury.



Still, all is forgiven. You are a big kid, and a huge pro football road grader. We love ya.

Sunday, September 02, 2007

Frank the Tank


Sure he looks semi-retarded in this picture, but Torrance "Tank" Daniels had a great football nickname and, more importantly in the Eagles' current LB scheme of things had more size and team experience than just about anyone else left on the defensive roster. So it came as a big surprise that he follows fellow Eagle veteran LB Jeremiah Trotter out the door on the last round of roster cuts. Indeed, Daniels initially appeared to be the big winner in the Trotter whacking two weeks ago. At 6'3" 248 lbs., he had the requisite size to sub for Gaither, perhaps even platoon with Gaither, at MLB with Trotter out of the way.

His waiving means that rookie Stewart Bradley is now the backup at both strongside and middle LB. And some guy named Akeem Jordan is the 3rd stringer at both positions behind Bradley (though we wonder about that MLB depth chart since Jordan is 10 lbs lighter than Gaither!).

The mind reels at all of the ramifications. Daniels must not have been very good, all his time on the practice squad notwithstanding. Indeed, he joins an long list of practice squad LBs that were being groomed to replace Trotter but couldn't make the plays when the games were for real. Mike Labinjo and Greg Richmond anyone?

The coaches must be very, very high on Stewart Bradley. Were the LBs so bad last year that the three positions will see 3 new starters and 2 new backups? They are placing an awful lot of faith in Gaither and Gocong with no safety net or plan B if they stumble. And thinking of how confident the Reid brain trust was of Matt McCoy at this time last year, that prospect should make any Eagle fan nervous. Speaking of which, if the LBs were so bad that they jettisoned Trotter, Jones, and Daniels, moved Gaither and brought in Spikes, how is it that Matt McCoy is still on the team?!

Interesting/Big Name players cut

Culling the list of final roster cuts of teams across the NFL are some surprise starters from last year, recent big-time FA acquisitions, and more than a few players with the talent and at positions that could help bolster the Eagles roster.

Perhaps the biggest cut was Jax starting QB Byron Leftwich, their 2003 #1 pick. Other notable cuts and other roster moves (i.e., placed on PUP):

Pats' Richard Seymour (PUP)
Bengals' LB Edgarton Hartwell and WR Reggie McNeal (wouldn't Hartwell be worth a look in a platoon/part-time situation?)
Priest Holmes (placed on the non-football injured list.he's still in football?)
Pats' LB Chad Brown and QB Vinny Testaverde
S Donovan Darius (Oak)
Bears rookie QB Chris Leak
Miami FB Corey Schlesinger and WR Az Hakim
Cleveland QB Ken Dorsey
Skins' DL Renaldo Wynn and rookie LB Dallas Sartz (Sartz would be a good project for the Eagles. He'll probably wind up on someone's practice squad.)
Cowboys' CB Aaron Glenn, OL Trey Darilek, and K Martin Grammatica placed on IR
Steelers' RB Verron Hayes
Jets' Andre Wadsworth and DL Kimo von Oelhoffen
Our old friend Billy McMullen in Minnesota. That trade for Hank Baskett looks better and better.
Another old friend DL Sam Rayburn was let go in San Fran.
Another former Eagle, Scott Peters was let go in Arizona.
Texan WR Bethel Johnson and Keenan McCardell
Dhani Jones, LB, Saints - 'nuff said.
DB J.R. Reed was let go by the Giants as was Will Demps

Saturday, September 01, 2007

Cuts?

If the Inqy sources and a buggy Eagles website are to be believed, Dirk Johnson and Jeremy Bloom are about 45 minutes away from being cut.

Both moves surprise me. Sal Rocca has the stronger leg, but Johnson really stepped up his game during the punting competition. Many thought the tie-breaker would be David Akers' preference for a place holder. On that score, Johnson seemed to have the upper hand. Sure, he wasn't Akers' favorite last year, perhaps a large part of the reason Akers' was uncharacteristically less accurate in figgies, but anyone could see that Rocca was worse in his several holds in the preseason. He couldn't get the laces right in the Ravens game where Akers missed, and he also didn't have them oriented correctly on another kick that Akers still managed to make.

Bloom's departure would be very surprising. He was a bit of a disappointment in the pre-season return game, but if he is cut the Eagles don't appear to have a plan B - other than Bucky returning kicks and Greg Lewis (yikes!) returning punts?!?! I mean, how bad could Bloom have been to the point where Reid prefers G. Lew?

More bizarrely, it would also mean that Bill Sampy is somehow, miraculously rewarded for getting hurt at the beginning of training camp and being unable at all to show what he could, or more likely couldn't do.

Friday, August 31, 2007

A Return to Glory?

For the newly revitalized and expanded Ches-Mont League? This was one of the premier football and high school sports leagues in the Philadelphia area back in the 1980s. Alas, it fell on hard times after some of the smaller schools – St. Pius X (always a tough opponent), Spring-Ford, etc. - pulled out in the face of a growing enrollment disparity among the Downingtown and West Chester schools, particularly Downingtown.

 

“Five of the new members - Great Valley, Kennett, Octorara, Oxford and Unionville - and former Del-Val League member Sun Valley will form the smaller schools American Division in football. Sun Valley, which will also compete this season in soccer, will join in all other sports in 2008.

 

Bayard Rustin, the newest school in the West Chester School District, will also join the American Division. Octorara will play only a junior varsity schedule the first year.

 

Avon Grove, Bishop Shanahan, Coatesville, Downingtown East, Downingtown West, West Chester East and West Chester Henderson will make up the big school National Division,” reports the Inqy. Alas, W. Chester East is not mentioned as a contender for the football title.

 

TO regrets McNabb relationship

Ten questions for Terrell Owens in Time Magazine. This one caught my eye.

 

“Do you regret how your relationship with quarterback Donovan McNabb turned sour in Philadelphia? David Sansone, PHILADELPHIA

 

You know what? I do regret some of the things that happened. Donovan is a great guy. Honestly, I do miss being around him. I learned some things from Donovan. It was a bad situation, and if there were a way I could go back and handle some things differently, I definitely would.”

Super Bowl or Bust for Eagles

So says the Sporting News. Great McNabb quote about “sealing the deal.”

Mama!

Yesterday afternoon’s thrilling bottom of the 9th inning come-from-behind win (against Billy Wagner no less!) reminded me of another thrilling Phillies’ rally on Mother’s Day 1993.

 

On May 9, 1993, the Cardinals were winning 5-2 going into the bottom of the 8th (Phillies starter Curt Schilling had left the inning before after giving up 4 earned runs and throwing 118 pitches). Cardinals starter Bob Tewksbury faced the heart of the Phillies order in the bottom of the 8th: their 3-4-5 hitters.

John Kruk struckout to start the inning. Dave Hollins tapped back to the pitcher for the 2nd out. But then Darren Daulton singled and Wes Chamberlained doubled, sending Daulton to third.

In came imposing closer Lee Smith to stop the nonsense. He walked Milt Thompson on a full count. The tying run was now on base.

 

Up came free swinging SS Mariano Duncan. He drove the first pitch into the left center field stands for a grand slam and the 6-5 lead. I can still recall all of this because my brother and I, along with several other friends, were over at our buddy Wolffie’s house and as the Phils continued to put runners on in the eighth (with two outs) our attention turned more and more to the game on TV. And when Duncan hit the grand slam I vividly remember the pandemonium in his living room with about 8-10 of us jumping up and down and high fiving each other like the Phils had just won the pennant. (Of course, it being the Phils, we had to endure a Mitch Williams 9th. Though I can’t recall this part of the game nearly as well, the box score indicates that Willams got the first two outs of the inning (one on a deep fly to left center), and then allowed a single before getting Ozzie Smith to pop up to the hero of the game, Mariano Duncan.)

 

There was something about that game. It’s easy in retrospect to see it as a harbinger of that magical ’93 season. It was all on display that day: the clutch hitting, the contributions from every part of the lineup, the Wild Thing ninth’s, and the never say die attitude. That last part can’t be overemphasized enough: that team never felt like it was out of a game, even down by 5 runs in the 9th  there was always a sense that they could rally. It was a feeling that became a self-fulfilling prophecy.)

 

But it wasn’t just in hindsight. There was something about that game AT THE TIME that gave every Phillies fan the feeling that there was something special about this team, something special about this season. And we all enjoyed the ride (well, right up to the 9th inning of game 6 in Toronto).

I also think there was something about the collective experience of watching that game. A bond was formed with all of us in Wolff’s living room, with each other and that team. Call it karma or whatever you want, but there was some sort of psychic power harnessed by all of us that bore witness to the magic of that game. It’s hard to explain, but if you watched that game you’d know the feeling you had about the ’93 Phillies after May 9.

Fast forward fourteen years. Yesterday’s win was Mother’s Day 1993 all over again. For a team that has suffered through bad bounces and the body blows of continual injuries, the series against the Mets up to yesterday was a reversal of fortune. Seemingly every bounce and break started to go the Phillies way, from Aaron Rowand’s 40 foot trickler that nestled on the foul line to Marlon Anderson being called out for interference that transformed a tie game into a game ending double play win.

 

But all of that was a prelude to yesterday’s 11-10 slugfest. Here are samples of the string of emails I sent out to friends yesterday as I listened to the game on my work computer:

·         Phils up 5-0 in the 3rd after Burrell hit a 2 run HR (his career 40th and 101 RBIs vs. Mets) and then a HR by Rowand! Not to overstate the obvious, but a sweep is the difference between 2 games in the standings

·         Rowand just caught a Conine drive at the top of the left center wall.

·         Inning later, Werth just climbed the out of town scoreboard wall to rob Beltran. I’m starting to get a special feeling about the Phils.

·         The relay throw that would have nailed Carlos Ruiz by 15 feet as he tried to stretch a double into a triple just hit him in the back….safe. Everything is bouncing their way.

·         Mets 4 run 8th (so far) gives them 9-8 lead, including stolen 3rd base and score on dropped throw. Why replace Romero with Alfonseca? Why?! Why!? Why?!

·         Burrell just hit HR to narrow lead. Met killer indeed.

·         Jimmy Rollins might just end this game right now in the bottom of the 9th.

 

Once again, everyone contributed, including guys like Taguchi, Werth, and Ruiz, there was clutch hitting galore, a high-wire reliever (take your pick, Gordon or Alfonseca, who couldn’t get a single Met out yesterday), and that “never say die spirit.” And like the Mother’s Day come from behind win against the Cardinals, this one too completed a series sweep.

 

But here’s the eerie part. A lot of people I know were either watching or listening to yesterday’s game live. My brother had it on his car radio on a drive up to Philadelphia. I had it on my computer. Our friend Crow, who was in Wolff’s living room with us in 1993, was actually at the game. My stepfather just happened to be home, turned on the TV in the late innings and became fixated by the drama. Even my Mom for some reason was listening to it at work. My point is, that a lot of people were following this game live, a surprisingly high number (albeit from my limited perspective) for a Thursday afternoon game. My point is this: This team just got sprinkled with the collective pixie dust. August 30. Mark it down. Anything is now possible.

Thursday, August 30, 2007

2007 Projection

Texas viewpoint of Eagles potential.

Mets-Phils

Jimmy Rollins might just end this game right now in the bottom of the 9th.

Ugh

Why replace Romero with Alfonseca? Why?! Why!? Why?!

 

I am a big fan of Romero – relative to the rest of the bullpen. I would like to see him get a more prominent role and be put in later in the game.

 

Burrell just hit HR to narrow lead. Met killer indeed.

Never mind

Mets 4 run 8th (so far) gives them 9-8 lead, including stolen 3rd base and score on dropped throw.

 

Gotta Believe?

The relay throw that would have nailed Carlos Ruiz by 15 feet as he tried to stretch a double into a triple just him in the back….safe. Everything is bouncing their way.

Phils-Mets

Rowand just caught a Conine drive at the top of the left center wall. Inning later, Werth just climbed the out of town scoreboard wall to rob Beltran.

 

I’m starting to get a special feeling about the Phils.

Phils-Mets

Phils up 5-0 in the 3rd after Burrell hit a 2 run HR (his career 40th and 101 RBIs vs. Mets) and then a HR by Rowand!

 

Not to overstate the obvious, but a sweep is the difference between 2 games in the standings

jfadklsfjsd;ouaid

Listening to the game on WPHT last night, the two announcers were incomprehensible for about 30 seconds during the attempted double play in the top of the 9th. They were only able to offer a stream of gibberish intermixed with the roars of the crowd that drown everything out and signified at least that SOMETHING big had just happened. Finally, they were able to intelligibly bleat out “it’s a double play, the game is over, the Phils win.”

Considine is No Lewis

Sure Michael Lewis’ coverage skills were a liability last year (remember the Saints regular season game?), but Lewis always hit like a truck. Sean Considine, his replacement, is better in coverage and reportedly put on 10-15 lbs – presumably of muscle – to fill the Strong Safety punch lost by Lewis’ leaving.

If the Steelers game is any indication, Considine’s offseason workout results are disappointing at best.

Which of the two Considine plays stands out more?

The one where he tried to bring the wood to an exposed TE Heath Miller on a floating pass down the middle? Considine not only failed to jar Miller enough to prevent him from catching it, he literally bounced off Miller as the big TE rumbled down to the goal line.

But the more bizarre play was later in the game also down near the goal line. The Steelers RB was being tackled inside the ten and Considine came up to add another punishing lick to the runner. With the runner’s momentum nearly dead stopped (he was practically on the ground at that point), Considine lowered his head hit the runner and the Eagle tackler….AND CONSIDINE BOUNCED BACKWARD LANDING ON HIS CAN.

The two plays could be chalked up to fluke plays except for the physical manhandling the Eagles’ defense experienced, and which makes Considine “physicality” a looming problem. With Omar Gaither being manhandled in the middle, Considine’S less than imposing presence could compound a small and weak defense.

Tuesday, August 28, 2007

Simon Sighting

Maybe with Corey Simon still in the league, we can finally find out what his non-football related malady was.

Monday, August 27, 2007

Ole Gaither

Ok, anyone else more mystified by the release of Trotter and more concerned about middle LB after watching Omar Gaither – whose size made him look more like a D-back than a LB last night (no surprise, he’s only 13 lbs heavier than Michael Lewis) – get manhandled at the point of attack on numerous occasions last night?

 

If the Eagles coaches were so concerned about Trotter’s second half performance last year, why didn’t they make middle LB a draft priority in April? It would appear that LB should have been a higher priority than QB for the Eagles this year. Paul Posluszny and David Harris would have been a better pick – would certainly play more – than Kevin Kolb this season.

 

I don’t necessarily blame Gaither. He’s a weakside LB being put in a bad position for which he simply doesn’t have the size. I do blame Reid and Heckert for drafting Matt McCoy instead of Kirk Morrison, the repercussions of that highly questionable pick will be felt all season.

 

Spikes will be the middle LB by the 4th game of the season.

 

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Super 5

A friend writes:

Funny thing about Eags fans, those of us that live away from Philly - away from the caldron, away from WIP, away from Angelo Cataldi's morning show - we know that the only way this team wins a Super Bowl is on No 5's shoulders.
A great defense and a great Westbrook season gets us to the NFC championship, but McNabb's the one who can carry us across the finish line.

Sadly, too many inside the 215 area don't see it as clearly as those of us who get the extra vision of looking at it from a distance.

 

My Take on Trotter

Having time to process it, I think the Eagles were penny-wise and pound foolish…again. Please excuse the following lengthy rant.

 

I agree with all of Besty’s points – the most obvious that apparently NO ONE else is talking about is that for a defense that everyone was so concerned was undersized, you’ve now got a middle LB at 235 lbs. Even given Trotter’s lost 9 lbs, Gaither is 20 lbs.!! lighter than Trotter.

 

My only question would be regarding Trotter’s pride? Did he not want to be a backup? Did he not want to restructure? Was there an issue with him playing special teams? Did the Eagles even offer either of those possibilities to him before cutting him loose?.

 

I find it interesting that among all that talk last year about our defensive line being inadequate at stopping the run, there was not much talk about Trotter’s performance. Now that the decision is made we get Rich Hoffman and Les Bowen telling us that “Rumors started last winter that when the coaching staff reviewed film of the 2006 season, the biggest surprise was how slow Trotter looked, and how much teams had really targeted him in their game-planning. Officially, the word was that Trotter needed to lose weight, and that if he did, he would more or less split the job this season with smaller, quicker second-year linebacker Omar Gaither, who probably wouldn't start, but would play most passing downs.” (Bowen) Really? This a question for reporters. Bowen’s article suggests that he heard these “rumors” 6 months ago. Then again, it could read that Bowen is now merely publishing the Eagles’ coaching staff’s revisionist interpretation of Trotter’s play to justify the decision. Which do you think it is? And if Bowen heard the rumors last winter, doesn’t he have some sort of obligation to report it? It’d be interesting if his articles back then focused solely on Dhani Jones and Darwin Walker and the d- line and if they make any mention, even subtly to Trotter or the interior linebacker play.

 

And we get Rich Hoffman and the numbers don’t lie. “In 2005, teams threw at the Eagles on first down 38 percent of the time. In 2006, that went up to 47 percent of the time - a very big leap. The result was first down last year became the

Eagles' worst down, by far, when you look at the yards they allowed.”

 

Fine. I get it. Trotter was becoming a liability. But he would have been a nice security blanket if all these new LBs – and I include Spikes in that group – can’t play. Plus, AT THE VERY LEAST TROTTER COULD HAVE PLAYED IN GOAL LINE SITUATIONS.

 

And really, was a slow Trotter any worse than Kirkland or Barry Gardner? I would think Trotter’s presence in the locker room would be enough to justify $2.6 million this year. This is a team that in theory is a super bowl contender. I understand the move a lot more if this team were rebuilding and you were just cutting dead wood. God forbid Gaither or Spikes go down, or Gocong can’t play. Then we’ll see the likes of Tank Daniels and Matt McCoy in there. And Daniels is a perennial practice squader who the coaches “like” just as they did with Mike Labinjo and Greg Richmond, two other Trotter heirs apparent that never panned out.

 

(for this same super bowl contender reasoning, I think it would insane to get rid of Kelly Holcomb and keep Kolb as the #3 starter. Your “injury-prone” starter is coming of a torn ACL. If he goes down, you have AJ Feeley, which is as capable a back up as you get these days in the NFL, but then Kolb, an untested rookie is the backup and the Eagles are then scrambling to pull someone off the waiver wire – remember Omar Jacobs? On the positive sign, maybe they could re-sign Detmer, who could also hold for Akers. And why Feeley isn’t holding for Akers is a whole other email exchange for another day). Why not put Kolb on the practice squad and keep Holcomb as insurance? The man has played in playoff games, while Kolb hasn’t even played in a real game yet.

 

The fact is that since they drafted Trotter, middle LB has been a disaster when he wasn’t starting. Would the Tampa championship game have turned out different if he were playing instead of Gardner and Kirkland? Perhaps. Gardner, Kirkland, Caver, McCoy, Simoneaux, Jones, Wayne, #57 whose name escapes me – it’s the one position the Eagles do not evaluate well

 

Plus, Trotter’s relationship with the Eagles has been star-crossed for years now. Yes, Trotter was unrealistic to seek Urlacher and Ray Lewis type money after his first contract, but let’s face it, Reid really screwed him by franchising him and then removing the tag in early summer after most teams had filled their LB needs. There is a fine line between making hard personnel choices among aging veterans, and completely undermining them. Trotter’s return was a feel good story capped off by his pro bowl selection. Why put a damper on that feeling among the other players and the fans? (don’t discount the fans’ affection for Trotter, which I think Reid should have at least taken slightly into account. Sure, it’s a business, but it’s also a sport played on emotion, keeping Trotter – particularly if he could make a couple of plays a game – would have helped with that, certainly at the Linc).

 

Finally, sadly, his waiver is the continuation of Reid’s MO. One that I think is too often short-sighted. For instance, why cut Hugh Douglas, a clubhouse leader and McNabb booster, when you knew you were going to have trouble with TO in year 2? His worth in maintaining some order in the locker room would have been more valuable than the contributions he could have made on the field. And as an active player, his credibility would have been more enhanced than the “ambassador” role he played when he punched out TO mid way through the season.

 

Same thing with Ike Reese. A special teams leader, fan favorite, and Reid-disciple. Why not throw him an extra million or use the veteran exemption on him to keep him in Philly? Maybe he really wanted to try to be a starting LB, but I think if the Eagles had made even a halfway fair offer, he would have stayed. Sure the Eagles have a reputation for not overpaying old players, but giving each of these guys something would have gone a long way to blunting some of those criticisms and showing the locker room that the Eagles reward loyalty and leadership on occasion.

 

 Same thing with Trotter now.

 

All I know is that Tiki Barber said that Jeremiah Trotter was the guy that always hit him the hardest and left him most sore after games.

Axing the Ax Man

Comments and reactions from friends on the stunning departure of Jeremiah Trotter:

 

JG: Can't really go against Reid and personnel decisions too much.  I thought Trotter looked bad against Ravens.  Still slow.

I can't believe he's not better than Tank Daniels, but maybe the "emotional talk" they had dealt w/ backup role and Trotter still wants to start.  I've been going with that in my head.  That's why they cut him now so he can catch on w/ another team.  I hope that's not it because if it is then I say screw him - make him backup and give us depth.  I hope he really is done.

 

 

PK: Personally, I know it's tough to see a beloved vet go but this is part of the reason we're considered such a top notch organization, making those calls correctly. If Trotter was too old to play on anything other than 1st down or really short yardage situations, we couldn't afford to pay him the big $$$$. And also, this defense has been led physically and emotionally for 3 or 4 yrs by BDawk, clearly. Trotter was a leader on D, but Dawkins is The Leader.
That said, what's our plan to stuff the run this year? Do we have one? Crossing our fingers and hoping we're better? It's been the Achilles of Johnson's D since '04 (when Trotter got reinserted as a starter solely to stuff the run in the final 8 games). The Saints exploited this in reg season and in NFC playoffs last year - ending our season with clock killing precision against our helpless defense. (Only a Brees miscue gave us the ball back late in the 4th in playoffs.)
Is Omar Gaither ready to become the Trotter of '99-'00-'01?  Not sure.

 

MB: It was totally to save money.  Why else do you cut Trot and keep McCoy?   Trot's already been contacted by NYG.  So, up the middle on defense we have, Bunkley(essentially a rookie who's been a bum to date), Patterson(undersized), Gaither (never played the middle before, undersized), Dawkins (aging, has hardly practiced or played in preseason due to injury) and Considine(white guy, undersized). Our linebackers are Spikes (15 games in last 2 years), Gaither (see above), Gocong (never played linebacker in his life, NFL rookie).  They generally do make good decisions regarding older players (Vincent, Taylor), but they better be right, because their judgment on linebackers has been horrendous.  Outside of Trot, our other MLB's have been Gardner, Kirkland and Simoneaux.  They were only paying Trot $2.6 this year.  Not a ton, but a lot for a backup.  Why not ask him to restructure and see if he takes the offer?   Seems like quite a gamble for a team in the hunt in a WIDE open NFC.  In the interviews with Dawkins, he said all the right things about letting Trot go, but his attitude was, "I hope they're right." 

Saturday, August 18, 2007

Andrews Watch

Getting a lot more concerned about Shawn Andrews' ankle injury. Les Bowen has a great, short story on the possibly much more severe condition Andrews could have, osteonecrosis.

www.philly.com/philly/sports/eagles/20070818_Sources__Andrews_injury_could_be_serious.html

It's all very conspiratorial. Reid says Andrews will be fine. Andrews is in tears talking about what could be a much more significant injury. Interestingly, as Bowen notes, Reid flatly denied the more serious possibilities of Andrews' injury. Would he do that if he had any inkling it could be much more serious. Doubtful, even for Reid. Stay tuned, and keep an eye on Max Jean-Gilles.

Friday, August 17, 2007

War Without Death

The Washington Post’s Mark Maske, the former beat reporter for the Redskins till owner Danny Snyder got him reassigned after threatening to pull his advertising cause he didn’t like the negative stories about mediocre on-field performance and dysfuncational team office leadership, has a new book out. It chronicles last season in the NFC East, called War Without Death.

Asking for Permission

Sorry, I just can’t help but wonder about such things…so how do you think Jenna’s suitor goes about getting an appointment with the President of the United States to ask for his daughter’s hand in marriage?

Rocket Tocchet

With the national attention on crooked NBA ref and O’Hara grad Tim Donaghy, how has this NHL gambling- involving former Flyer Rick Tocchet- been able to fly under the radar screen?

Thursday, August 16, 2007

G'day Mate

Sal Rocca is built like a LB and can take a hit like an LB. Here’s a link to the vicious shot he took Monday night vs. the Ravens. Aside from it being a very cheap shot, the Raven should have been kicked out of the game for leading with the crown of his helmet in a helmet-to-helmet hit. Also, I’ll echo the announcers’ kudos for Gasperson for standing up for his punter.

Monday, August 13, 2007

Bunkley a Junkyard Dog

Les Bowen tackles the hound that didn’t bark concept with B. Bunkley’s play.

Tiger Take

After Tiger Woods won his 13th major yesterday without being seriously challenged, we’re left wondering if there is any contemporary competition for him. The answer may go a long way toward defining his legacy. It hasn’t gotten a lot of attention yet, but in his ongoing quest to surpass Jack Nicklaus’ record of 18 major championships surely questions will begin to emerge about the quality of Tiger’s competition.

Think about it. Nicklaus won 18 majors playing against some of golf’s all-time greats: Arnie Palmer, Gary Player, Lee Trevino. Who, if anybody, is in that class among Tiger’s colleagues? Sergio Garcia? Please. Still hasn’t won a major. Justin Leonard? Remember him? Vijay Singh? Phil Mickelson, he of the man boobs? Be serious. Woody Austin and Bob May – journeymen he has beaten for previous championships? Maybe his most formidable rival will be Ernie Els. But revelations in yesterday’s broadcast make me skeptical. Tiger is playing for history and destiny. Els is playing, so said the CBS announcers, to win the “career grand slam.” (he’s got 2 of the 4 legs: the US and British Opens). It hardly seems a fair fight, they’re playing for two radically different goals.

It is worth noting that Tiger has more major championships than the rest of the top 10 players combined.

It sort of reminds me of the Larry Holmes era in boxing. Ali was champion in an era with Sonny Liston, Joe Frazier, George Foreman, Ken Norton and Ernie Shavers. Holmes (the Easton Assassin) was the subsequent champ who reigned over a mediocre (at best) heavyweight division in which Leon Spinks and Jerry Quarry were considered top contenders. Indeed, Spinks was briefly champion. It was so bad that Randall “Tex” Cobb and Ed Too Tall Jones took up boxing and were considered serious fighters.

Without a doubt, Tiger - along with Nicklaus – is of the two greatest golfers of all time. But in another major or two, hard questions are going to have to be asked about his reign. Is he pummeling the field into submission? Or is the field so bereft of talent – certainly less talent then when Nicklaus played – capable of making it a competitive contest.

Down the Crapper

What’s that noise in the bathroom? Just Will Heaton flushing his career down the toilet.

Game Preview

A Baltimoron view of the Eagles preseason game tonight in Charm City vs. the Ravens. “I love it when the Eagles come to town. It's the only time all year you're allowed to tailgate outside Central Booking.”

Thursday, August 09, 2007

Incredible but true

My brother and friend are in Saratoga for the horse races. They have been betting on the local action, but also simulcasts from tracks across the country. They put a$1 on the superfecta on the 3rd race at Louisiana Downs…and won! $8,000 schemolas. They got their picture taken when they cashed the ticket, but the OTB withheld two grand for taxes (they’re going to be getting 1099 forms.). So if you see two stumbling, drunken bums up in Saratoga today, they’ve got $6,000 in cash burning a hole in their pockets.

Incredible.

State of the Team - in Dog Terms

The NFL is, beyond doubt, the premier sports league in the United States. Because of the sport’s popularity, the teams’ owners are treated to ridiculous obsequiesness. The pompastic use of “Mr. Lurie” or “Mr. Rooney” in reference to the owner is the biggest case in point. And so, too is the presumptuousness of a “State of the Team” address. Please.

Worse is Lurie’s revisionist history during his address the other day. In regards to Michael Vick’s dog fighting charges, Lurie noted how in recent years Thomas Hamner and Damon Moore were found guilty of animal abuse and quickly discharged from the team. If that it were so.

Damon Moore was the starting strong safety in the 2001 NFC Championship game vs. the Rams. The only reason the team released him was cause he blew out his knee late in that game and was never the same. Message? Not that the Eagles abhor animal cruelty, but that if you can play, they will look the other way….until you can’t play anymore.

Afford to Lose

A friend is non-plussed by the Westbrook camp departure and suggests that “bigger concern is the B-Dawk achilles tendinitis.  That is said to be a precursor to Achilles tear.  They oughtta shut him down now.”

Vote in the poll to the right about the Eagle player the team can least afford to lose.



36 Emergency

Brian Westbrook has left camp for “personal reasons” and may not be back. Usually losing your star running back with such bizarre and ambiguous news would prompt some sort of investigative reporting or comprehensive coverage. Alas, all we get from the Inqy is a strange video of Eagles beat writer Bob Brookover’s reaction. Who cares about his reaction? Let’s get some info please!