Friday, October 05, 2007

Manuel's Mess

Charlie Manuel may not be the worst manager in the Phillies-Rockies series (Hurdle’s still inexplicable batting of Jeff Francis in the top of the 7th inning – with a man on  - and then relieving him in the bottom of the 7th without throwing a single pitch remains the high standard Manuel would have to meet for truly outstanding managerial incompetence), but because his team is down 2-0 in the series, he’s getting the disproportionate share of scrutiny.

 

Toward that end, Phil Sheridan today gives a remarkably detailed account of Manuel’s decision-making in replacing starter Kyle Kendrick with starter cum reliever Kyle Lohse in the top of the fourth inning, with two outs and the bases loaded. Lohse gave up the grand salami to Kaz Matsui that “broke the game open” but in reality made it a very manageable (for the Phillies offense) 6-3 game.

 

Sheridan covers it all: the lead up to that inning including previous Phillies bullpen action; the squib single that signaled Kendrick’s end; Matsui’s fateful at bat; The 1-2 count that Lohse got Matsui too. And this summary: “One misplaced pitch is the difference between a 3-2 lead and a 6-3 hole. It's the difference between Manuel looking smart and strapping that lightning rod back onto his head.”

 

Fair enough. Though as my brother pointed out, bringing in a starter out of the bullpen in that situation – bases loaded – is especially tough. I’d elaborate on that. I don’t necessarily blame Manuel for taking Kendrick out there. My bigger question is why not bring in Gordon or Romero instead? It’s a critical at bat, a critical scoring situation for the Philllies. Why not bring in one of your top relievers to shut the door on the threat? Like an old fashioned “Rolaids Fireman.”

 

Why bring in Lohse in that situation? Why not bring in Gordon or, better yet, Romero, have him pitch the 5th and then bring Lohse in to start the 6th inning? Yes, it was the 2nd time Lohse had warmed up, but he couldn’t keep tossing to stay warm for one inning? In fact, Lohse wouldn’t even have been warming up the second time if Manuel had initially gone to one of his primary relievers.

 

In any case, the fixation with the Kendrick-Lohse decision overlooks the much bigger Manuel move. The Jose Mesa meltdown. The Phillies didn’t lose the game on the Lohse-Matsui grand slam. They lost it when the Rockies tacked on another four runs in the 6th. What was Mesa doing in there!?!?!?!? A 3 run deficit is surmountable. A 7 run lead, well, not so much.

 

It was a do or die game. So I’m not sure what Manuel’s rationale for calling on Mesa was at all. In fact, why did Manuel decide the pivotal game two was the time to pitch three of his most unreliable relievers – Mesa, Alfonseca, and Condrey? What the??!! It’s like Charlie gave up after the grand slam. The reality is that if you ‘re the Phillies, losing 6-3 in game two of a best of five series where you are already down one game to none, YOU CANNOT LET THE ROCKIES SCORE AGAIN. With that imperative in mind, you have to go with Romero, Gordon, and Myers to keep you in the game while you hope the offense gets the runs back. UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES DO YOU PUT YOUR +5.00 ERA RELIEVERS IN AT THAT POINT (Mesa – 5.54 era, Alfonseca – 5.44, Condrey – 5.04)!!!! Thank God Eaton wasn’t on the roster, or Manuel may have been tempted to pitch him at some point in game 2.

 

If the Phils had been able to keep it a 6-3 game, or even a 7-3 game, then the bottom of the 8th bases loaded takes on a whole new pressure for the Rockies. As it was, the Phillies never got the tying run to the plate. Without Mesa’s immolation, they likely would have at some point. And then, perhaps, the Phillies could have reversed the 4th inning roles – and maybe – results. And it also would have changed the complexion of the game in the 9th  when the Phils got two runners on and Ryan Howard at bat. A score of 7-5 at that point is a lot more fraught with danger for the Rockies than 10-5.

 

Manuel made some bad, bad pitching decisions in game 2. Decisions that helped the Phillies lose the game. Just not the decision most of the Philly media is looking at.

Duke Lacrosse

Just another reminder of the two systems of justice we have in this country: one for rich, white people – or in this case kids – and one for everyone else – mainly poor and minority. There are people that have spent years on death row only to be exonerated later due to faulty evidence, prosecutorial misconduct, and questionable police activity. Of course, not being Duke students they never sued for $30 million. The sense of entitlement boggles the mind. On the flip side is the  Rosenbaum family who sued Washington, DC for the negligent EMS response that lead to David Rosenbaum’s death. They won, but didn’t want money – only reforms to the city’s fire and rescue services. Finnerty, Seligmann, and Evans could take a page out of that book.

A Gnawing Bitterness

My friend PK is bitter about how the Phillies NLDS has played out so far. Compounding his frustration is the series/TV schedule.

 

He writes: “I got to watch 1 1/2 innings of my team's first playoff game in 14 years. I will likely watch none of today's game. I am in a position in life where taking off work is not a plausible thing to do in life. This sucks.

The reason why? "RedSoxNation" and the yankees.

TV sports execs are no different than the Hollywood tv/movie people who are so creatively bankrupt they keep churning out sequels of once popular movies and spinoffs of once popular tv shows. Sports producers are just praying for a BoSox-Yanks series, because they know it did so well in '03-'04. So they give every one of their games prominent timing.

F-u, TBS and MLB. F! U!”

Thursday, October 04, 2007

Gruden to Return?

Fresh off Paul Domowitch ‘s “Andy Reid’s family issues are affecting the team” article this morning, my West Chester buddy Wolffie says that rumors abound that Reid is on his way out and Jon Gruden (?!?) is set to take over the team. Not sure about the Reid portion of that – though I think where there is smoke, there is fire.

But the Gruden part doesn’t make too much sense. After several lean years in the wake of his super bowl victory, Gruden finally appears to have righted the ship in Tampa. I can’t believe he wouldn’t want to put several more winning years in down there to dispel any of the whispers that Gruden’s championship came about mostly because of Tony Dungy’s players and that Gruden on his own hasn’t made the Bucs a consistent winner. Then again, Gruden does have a history with the Eagles and Jeff Lurie. Gruden was the offensive coordinator under Ray “I want players who make plays” Rhodes during Lurie’s first five years as owner. And next to Rhodes, Lurie must think Gruden was a freakin' coaching genius. And if not, well, Gruden would be sure to tell him that himself.

Back to the Eagles?

Like I said in an earlier post, the Phillies have a window of opportunity – what with the great NL East run, the first two home playoff games, and Eagles on a bye - to reclaim some Philly fan attention that has been disproportionately focused on the Eagles for, oh, the last decade. Anyway, as I also wrote, re-engaging a generation of potential baseball fans in the region was going to depend on how the NLDS went, and, more importantly, how the Phillies played.

 

Note to Pat Gillick and Dave Montgomery: Getting swept is NOT the way to engender yourself with prospective Phillies fans.

Game 3

“Yesterday is a wind gone down, a sun dropped in the West. I tell you that there is nothing in the world, only an ocean of tomorrows, a sky of tomorrow.”  - - Carl Sandburg.

 

"We gotta play it one day at a time." - - Ebby Calvin LaLoosh.

Game 2

Best line by the announcers: “Pitching for the Phillies, Kyle Kendrick. Whose name sounds like he should be driving in NASCAR.”

 

Jimmy Rollins is THE MAN.

 

Chase Utley, one of the top lefthanded hitters in the league, is 0-6 with 5 strikeouts  so far vs. Rockies southpaws.

 

 

Best Line of the Day

No – not Utley’s 0-4 with 4 strikeouts. On 13 pitches!

 

Not even Howard’s 0-4 with 3 strikeouts.

 

Phillies fans should take solace in the fact that they only lost 4-2 as their 3-4 hitters went a combined 0-fer 8, with 7! Ks -  Add in Jimmy Rollins’ double play with a 3-1 count, Charlie pinch running Michael Bourn who didn’t steal a base and then was promptly doubled up (what a waste), and the blown call on Holliday’s mammoth grand slam that was called foul as it left the stadium and the score could have, should have been much, much worse.

 

Anyway, the best line of the day was from the TBS studio guy – Ernie Johnson: “With Shane Victorino wearing the double earflap helmet and Jeff Francis, who looks like he’s 17, it’s like an American Legion game out there.”

 

All in the Family

For the first time, the Daily News’ Paul Domowitch delicately raises the issue of Andy Reid’s family life affecting his coaching and, thus, the Eagles performance. “The line between Reid's family issues and his team's poor play is starting to become blurred. While questions about his sons don't need to be asked of him right now, this one most certainly does: Are his personal problems starting to affect his ability to coach his football team?”

 

It’s a concern I’ve been hearing about from lots of fans – how else to explain Greg Lewis as a punt returner or no adjustments to address Umenyiora’s sack bonanza - but now its been publicly aired in a major venue.

 

If the Eagles season continues on its downward trajectory, expect this issue to become bigger and bigger – perhaps become THE issue - as the losses pile up.

Wednesday, October 03, 2007

Ump

howard just K'd in 9th on two straight balls that were called strikes.

Manuelesque.

Hurdle just let francis bat in the top of the 7th with a man on, and then replaced him before throwing a pitch in the bottom of the 7th.

Maybe charlie isn't the worst game manager in the playoffs.

jeff francis looks like he's in high school.

More like it

ok. Rowand & burrell with back to back homers has woken the moribund crowd up.

every hit this inning s even the outs - have been smashes.

So far

jimmy rollins' strikeout, after being ahead 3-0 in the count really seemed to take some of the wind out of the crowd's sail. Striking out the side just added to silence.

looks like hamels is getting squeezed on the inside of the plate - though the ump is giving both pitchers the outside.

Everyone should be happy it's only 3-0 since the ball Holliday hit out of the stadium with the bases loaded looked fair to me before it exited citizens bank.

Being There

So my Mom, stepdad, and uncle were all at Sunday's division clincher, #162. Now I get word from my brother that he is going to today's NLDS Game #1. Here's hoping I can get to a game soon. The NLCS???

Anyway, my Mom recorded the last out at Sunday's game on her cell phone. Here's the brief video. Note, the link may work better in Internet Explorer than Firefox.

Being There

So my Mom, stepdad, and uncle were all at Sunday's division clincher, #162. Now I get word from my brother that he is going to today's NLDS Game #1. Here's hoping I can get to a game soon. The NLCS???

Anyway, my Mom recorded the last out at Sunday's game on her cell phone. Here's the brief video. Note, the link may work better in Internet Explorer than Firefox.

Recapturing the Youth Market

For nearly a quarter century the Phils have been mired in mediocrity. Aside from the magical 1993 season - whose bitter ending may have permanently scarred some young fans, this team's decades-long trail of indifferent play has failed to engage - may actually have proactively turned off - an entire young generation of potential baseball fans. Compounding this misery, the Eagles during that same time have established themselves as the "gold standard" if not in the NFL, then at least in terms of professional sports franchises in Philadelphia. Indeed, younger fans may see all Eagles all the time, but Philadelphia has historically been - and remains - a strong if underrated "baseball town." As if any further proof is needed, the team often cracks 3 million in attendance for a perpetual .500 team that until very recently played in a non-descript "multipurpose" "stadium."

By dint of an unprecedented come from behind surge to capture the NL East and a NFL-MLB scheduling quirk, the Phillies have an opportunity to make amends for 25 years of futility and to make inroads with a new fan base. The 1-3 Eagles are floundering and, more importantly, on bye this week. The Phillies NLDS will go through the weekend. If they can win, the excitement and interest they will generate for the NLCS in the region could propel them to the top of the city's pro sports pecking order. At least in the short term. Whether the team can solidify the gains and make them permanent will largely hinge on how far they go and how they play ( i.e., either blown out and uncompetitive or playing cliffhanger games).

All of which is to say, that while Eagleseye is ostensibly a blog about the Eagles, it does cover Philadelphia sports in general. And with the Birds on a bye and the Phillies the most exciting athletic event in town, be warned that there will be lots more Phillies-related posts through October.

Go Phillies!

Grilling Gillick

Bill Conlin today picks up the theme about Pat Gillick's questionable personnel decisions covered here on Eaglesye last week. The key point in his article, "What were the odds on Opening Day that of Gillick's most important offseason moves, only Wes Helms, Greg Dobbs, Jason Werth and Rod Barajas would be on Manuel's postseason roster?"

Still, kind of strange timing for this to run. Couldn't this have been published yesterday? Why today, hours from the first Phillies playoff game in 14 years? C'mon Bill. Get with the program, feel the Citizens Bank love, and join the team/city/fans for the big win.

Tuesday, October 02, 2007

M-V-P

Add ESPN baseball writer (and former Philly Inqy baseball writer) Jayson Stark in the Jimmy Rollins is the NL MVP column.

Patriot Spy Games

Even NFL company man Peter King thinks there was fishy stuff with the way Roger Goodell and the league handled the Patriots/Belichick cheating “investigation.”

 

And I love how Patriots fans continue to be in denial and full victim mode now that there coaching “genius” was caught cheating and has now cast doubt on all their wins. Point in case is the Sport’s Guy who wrote, “My answer: In case you didn't notice, the Patriots have been in Screws-You Mode ever since the Mangini thing happened.”

 

Note he calls it the “Mangini thing.” As if the Patriots cheating is Eric Mangini’s fault. It’s like calling the famous 90’s double homicide the “Nicole Simpson thing.” Why sully OJ’s name by even mentioning it in the same breath as such a sordid incident. Oh that’s right. You do it cause they got caught.

 

And I also don’t get Simmons’ defense of the Pats running up the score now, “it's the most effective way to wave both middle fingers at the rest of the league and prove that they didn't need to cheat to win three Super Bowls.”

 

Huh? Wave a finger at the league cause they caught you cheating? The Patriots were caught cheating and they’re the victims? And how does Tom Brady throwing long TD bombs to newly acquired Randy Moss somehow “prove” that the Patriots didn’t need to cheat when David Patten and David Givens were their WR while “winning” super bowls?

 

Whatever.

On Second Down (Thought)

Further musings on the Eagles-Giants game. My previous reference to the Eagles passing yards – 138 – was gross passing yards gained. When you include the sacks, the Eagles netted 76 yards passing. Again, compared to 114 yards rushing (on 23 carries), it is even more inexplicable as to why there were so many more passes than running plays called. In fact, when you take McNabb’s four carries out of the rushing stats (4 carries for 4 yards on three scrambles and a QB sneak), the Eagles gained 110 yards on 19 carries – 5.8 yards a pop.

 

The Eagles continue to be one of the most penalized teams in the league. The Giants accepted 15 penalties and declined 2 others.  The Eagles only ran 54 plays. The penalty yardage pretty much zeroed out the gross passing yards. This undiscipline is all on Reid. Yesterday’s press conference had Reid giving a vote of confidence to punter Sal Rocca. Really, the Philly press should have been asking about his confidence in his special teams coach. The fact remains special teams have been a disaster this year. Jeremy Bloom was the pre-season fall guy. The question now is when Rory Segrest will be held accountable for the poor play and penalties.

 

The lone bright spot for the Eagles other than the running game (and Correll Buckhalter) was…as usual  - the defense.

 

I didn’t hear Gocong’s name called much, nor Spikes’ for that matter – except for that personal foul facemask. And I’ve heard some criticism about Omar Gaither being caught by Eli Manning (in Gaither’s defense, Manning did have a head start and Gaither did return his interception 49 yards.) But the Eagles D only gave up 10 points. On the road. That should be MORE than enough stops to win a game. And Jim Johnson did it without his pro bowl cornerback or his pro bowl safety and with his other starting CB suffering a stinger early in the game.

 

Johnson’s squad kept the Giants to 212 total yards, 135 passing for Manning – which, incredibly is less than McNabb had (not counting yardage lost to sacks). Johnson’s men even managed to hold the Giants to 3-11 3rd down efficiency, a perennial bugaboo in facing the Giants. Jim Johnson held up his end of the bargain with a depleted eleven. Andy Reid, the noted QB coach, did not. Same as it ever was with this team. Maybe someday the Eagles will get an offense comparable to its defense –though probably not while Andy Reid continues to insert himself into the offensive game plan.

 

Anyone else notice that at the end of the 1st half the referee screwed up the clock? With 39 seconds left the Eagles were whistled for a delay of game, but the Eagles and Giants ran the play and 6 seconds ran off the clock. The delay of game meant the play should never have occurred so the clock should not have run. The refs blew it by not whistling the play dead sooner/louder, and then compounded their error by not putting the 6 seconds back on the clock. It looked like the mistake was going to benefit the Eagles who were on the Giants side of the field and thinking last second score. But they wound up punting and the Giants, with less than 10 seconds left in the half (should have been 14) downed the ball and ran out the clock. It’s a small thing in the scheme of things, but it is an indication that Andy Reid is not paying attention to important details like the game clock to the detriment of his offense. It’s doubly troubling since he’s the head coach and supposedly in charge of time management. He’s even screwing that up!

 

Charlie Going to be Manager of the Year?!

Looks like Jimmy Rollins is now the odds on favorite to be NL MVP. Deservedly so.

 

But my friend PK writes about another potential award winning Phillie:

 

“Charlie Manuel is Manager of the Year. It scares me to say that, and yes, this means he'll be managing them again next season. But he's gonna be NL manager of the year. Unreal. Can't wait for the postseason.

 

Let's give Charlie his due for this past weekend-plus. He managed the boys, particularly the staff, pretty darn well. Saturday was actually genius in his bullpen work, giving the offense a chance to win the game (which it didn't). But he's a terrible in-game manager. Period.

 

The only more frustrating in-game coaching is from Andy Reid, who seems largely unaware he's got a QB who's 80% at best and is largely immobile. Andy keeps calling an inordinate # of passes vs. the run, and then - with his newly immobile QB - Andy doesn't do any max protect schemes, certainly none on NYG's No 72.”

Putting the Mets out of their Misery

Philly Phanatic Shoots Mr. Met.

Lt. Kendrick

Kendrick wasn’t even on the roster opening day. Now he’s our #2 pitcher in the post-season. And as noted before, our opening day starter is now in the bullpen. Weird season.

Rotation

Inqy reporting that the starting rotation will be Hamels, Kendrick, Lohse, and Moyer – and that Eaton may not be included on the roster.

 

My friend PK asks: “Just looking at that rotation scared the living crap out of me. Aside from Moyer, those starters have a combined 12 innings pitched in the postseason (all Lohse with the Twins) and just 1 start. With Hamels at 23, Kendrick at 22, is there any team in playoff history that went into postseason with its 2 lead pitchers being so young, so inexperienced? Prior and Wood are all I can think to compare, but those guys were in their mid-20s or later, I think, by the time the Cubs got to the '04 LCS.”

 

My brother suggests that having Hamels and Kendrick go in games 1 and 2 should help with the crowd at home.

 

 

Ceding the Field

My friend PK and I were at RFK stadium a week ago Friday for the Phillies-Nationals game. We noticed and commented on the phenomenon Bob Ford elaborates on today – the Eagles ceding fan attention to the Phillies. At RFK, where about 40% of the spectators were Phillies fans, we couldn’t help but notice the near complete lack of Eagles paraphernalia. In years past at September RFK games between the Nats and Phils, there have been plenty of Eagles hats, jerseys, and E-A-G-L-E-S cheers in the stands. But not this fall. We were both on the lookout but only saw one young man sporting an Eagles hat during the entire game. In a similar vein, several friends and I were all in agreement that the passion in Citizens Bank Park the past week has to have been a nice treat for the team which has had to endure Eagles cheers in their home stadium for years now. That’s not the case right now. It’s all Phillies, all the time.

 

(By the way, as an aside. At that Phillies-Nats game, we witnessed something unusual. When Flash Gordon came in to pitch the 8th, the “Big 3” – Howard, Utley, and Rollins – stood abreast about 8 feet behind the mound and just watched Gordon’s warm up pitches, like they were analyzing what Gordon’s stuff was. My friend PK theorized that the 3 could veto Manuel’s decision to pitch Gordon if the 3 didn’t like his velocity. At the least, they may have been figuring if Gordon was going to get hit a lot and if they were going to be busy in the field. The whole scene was noticeable and memorable cause it didn’t appear that the 3 were talking to each other, but all three were intently standing there observing Gordon’s warm up pitches. And it was also noticeable cause Abraham Nunez who had come in previously as a defensive replacement did not join the trio behind the mound, but stayed close by third base just standing there by himself.

 

Of course, what I find so remarkable about Ford’s article is the revelation that Eagles president Joe Banner calls reporters and editors to complain about too much media coverage of the other Philadelphia sports teams – presumably at the expense of the Eagles. He’s not complaining about negative Eagles coverage, but that other teams are getting too much. Not other NFL teams, but the other major sports teams in the city. That’s astounding.

 

“One high-ranking Eagles' executive whom we won't name (rhymes with Joe Banner) has been known to contact newspapers and media outlets when he thinks other teams are getting too much coverage,” writes Ford.

10 Times in 125 Years?

The great Philadelphia sports writer Bill Lyon, now retired, has become the 21st century equivalent of Kate Smith. Brought out for special sporting occasions. The Phillies improbable playoff appearance is just such an event worthy of Lyons’ pen.

 

But can it really be that the Phillies are in the post-season for only the 10th time in 125 years? 1915, 1950, 1976, 1977, 1978, 1980, 1981, 1983, 1993. More amazing, I’ve been alive and remember all but 1915 and 1950.

The Comeback

Everyone has referenced the 7 games back with 17 to play as the benchmark for how much incredible ground the Phillies made up in the last two and half weeks of the season. But really, isn’t two back with five to play even more indicative of the shocking turn of events? Especially since the Phillies won the division outright meaning that they picked up three games on the division leader in five total.

Monday, October 01, 2007

Jamie Moyer

Very cool profile by Thomas Boswell of local boy made good Jamie Moyer, who got the win in the biggest game of his career for the team he cheered for as a child. The most moving graph: “Moyer talked about what it meant to be a Phillies fan, wedded to a team famed for failure.

 

As the 44-year-old southpaw headed to Citizens Bank Park on Sunday morning, preparing to pitch the most important game of his life, he drove past a Little League field near the park.

 

‘There were kids playing. If I hadn't been pitching, I might have stopped. It brought up a lot of childhood memories for me, growing up less than an hour from here, rooting for Steve Carlton, going to the Phillies' parade after they won the World Series’ in 1980, Moyer said. ‘I got those warm and fuzzy feelings. It made me appreciate what I was going to have a chance to do. To be able to win in this city where I grew up, to be able to stand in this clubhouse now, I'm at a loss for words,’ said Moyer, who fell silent and calmly, as he does everything, started to cry.”

 

And the Boz neatly captures what it means to be a Phillie fan.

 

“Few understand the life of the Phillies fan, linked to a franchise that, this season, actually celebrated its 10,000th loss. Decades of frustration, all the way back to 1883, are interspersed with rare seasons -- like this one -- of precious but perishable opportunity. Maybe no one understands better than Moyer, the third-oldest player in the game, his history tangled with Philly's baseball fatalism -- expect the worst, hope for anything else. Phils fans don't call themselves a Nation or wear their disappointments on their sleeves. And they boo a lot, and with cause, since 97 years is quite a while to wait for one World Series win. No wonder Moyer played hooky from high school to see that parade.”

 

 

Worst Ever?

So where does the Mets’ collapse rank? Our junkball pitching friend “Fish,” a once aspiring minor league thrower and very knowledgeable baseball afficianado, offers his analysis.

 

“Statistically speaking, it's the worst. 

 

Borrowing from a cbssportsline.com article today:  ‘No major league team had owned a lead of seven games or more with 17 to play and failed to finish in first place. New York, which had that margin on Sept. 12, matched the largest lead blown in September. The 1934 New York Giants (Sept. 6) and 1938 Pittsburgh Pirates (Sept. 1) also led by seven games in the final month only to drop into a fatal tailspin.’

 

Emotionally, it's crushing.  you're talking about a team that went 1-6 in their final 7 games, all at home against the two worst teams in their own division.

 

Minaya has yet to stand up for Willie Randolph.  David Wright called out his teammates.  Glavine looked like he was throwing the game yesterday.  Milledge and Reyes doing their little home run dance that precipitated the brawl Saturday.  the Mets are a mess.

 

Add all that up and put it in the New York media?  worst.  collapse.  ever.”

Rank the Collapse

My friend PK asks:

“Where does the Mets loss ranks in terms of MLB collapses?

 

I mean, I don't think it's fair to compare these sorta collapses with playoff series like the '04 Yankees or the '86 Angels.

 

But I think there's a separate category for regular season collapses that we should consider. And several jump out, Obviously, as contenders, the '64 Phillies, the '69 Cubs, the '78 Red Sox, the '51 Dodgers and, now, the '07 Mets.

 

I think, certainly, we can say that in the 21st-century-style MLB -- with 4 teams from each league making the playoffs -- this is the worst collapse of this era. Now, compared to the others, it may be considered The Worst Ever simply because they didn't just lose the division, they fell completely out of the playoffs. The Phillies went from 1st place in the NL in '64 to a tie for 2nd place, 1 game off the Cards. The Brooklyn Dodgers collapsed, sure, but they actually ended the season tied for 1st and lost out in a really hard-fought game in the bottom of the 9th to one of the single most dramatic plays in the game's history.

 

The '78 Red Sox may be the only comparable thing, but it was longer and slower, a 2-month slow motion free-fall as opposed to the complete implosion that occurred in half a month for the Mets. And of course the Sox did manage to tie the Yanks and, like the '51 Dodgers, lost in the divisional playoff game to one of the more dramatic HR's ever (Bucky Dent).

 

This collapse was sooo spectacular, so pathetic, I'm not sure anything compares.”

From Cruel to Sadistic

The Eagles game last night certainly left a sour taste in the mouths’ of fans still savoring the sweet Phillies wine of a NL East division title. It wasn’t just the loss to the hated Giants that was so distasteful, but the manner in which it happened.

Andy Reid’s preference for the pass has officially gone from a curious fetish to pathological sickness. The Inqy’s Phil Sheridan calls it an “addiction.” Asking McNabb to throw 29 times with a sports hernia in a game his team won by six touchdowns was cruel. As was making McNabb pass 46 times versus the Redskins in a game they never trailed by more than 10 points and was only the second back from his ACL surgery.

But last night’s offensive “game plan” was simply sadistic. There is no other way to explain or describe it. It was sadistic to Winston Justice who was humiliated on national TV and it was sadistic to inflict such continuing punishment on Donovan McNabb who was sacked at least once on every drive the Eagles had in the game. And that doesn’t even count the number of hits and hurries #5 endured.

But the biggest question – beyond why so many pass plays (33 compared to 23 rushes) were called when the Eagles were running all over the Giants (5.0 yard/carry) – was why in the name of Jerome Brown Andy Reid and his enabler Marty Mohrninweg provided no help to Justice on the pass plays that were called!! It was INEXPLICABLE.

Even I know enough that you can help a tackle out by lining up the TE on his side to help double team, or at the least chip the defensive end at the beginning of his route. And/or keep a running back in the backfield to help double team the end or at least provide some semblance of insurance if the pass rusher gets by the tackle so he doesn’t have an uninterrupted route to the QB.

Certainly the coaches were aware of this. On at least several plays Reno Mahe helped Jon Runyan pick-up Strahan on the rightside of the line. The unexplained question is why the Eagles’ brain trust thought it prudent to help a pro bowl tackle handle an over the hill pass rusher, but not his left side counterpart making his first NFL start. After the third sack it didn’t take a genius to realize that Justice needed some help, any help, with Umenyiora.

Correll Buckhalter ran for 103 yards on 17 carries, a 6.1 average. On nearly twice as many pass attempts (31), the Eagles gained just 138 yards. My five year-old can calculate which is the more efficient and successful option.

And when you add in that your starting tight end was hurt and your “#1” WR Reggie Brown is showing a Pinkston-like ability to get open, it becomes even more unclear as to why Reid and Mohrninweg were so wedded to the pass.

If any good came out of last night’s game, it may be this. The evidence is accumulating that McNabb is not so much “injury-prone” as Andy Reid’s offense is prone to make his QB injured. Maybe we should marvel at McNabb’s durability and wonder how McNabb has only had three serious injuries with the Eagles when you see the game- in and game-out punishment he takes in Andy Reid’s pass happy “offense.” That and we all have a new appreciation for the rock William “Tra” Thomas has been at left tackle for the past decade.

Key to the Phillies Stretch Run

The main thing in this NY Times graphic documenting the ingredients of the Mets decline and the Phils ascension was the ERA of the Phillies’ bullpen since September 12. Phillies relievers had a 2.40 era since that date. The Mets’ relievers had a 5.27 ERA. Indeed, the Phils team ERA since 9/12 was 3.44. But it was the relief era that’s such a surprising twist for what was – and remains – the weakest part of the team. Still, in crunch time the bullpen delivered. And the Mets’ pitching staff? Not so much. In fact, the offenses performed similarly in the last 17 games, but it was the Phillies pitchers that made the difference.

 

And Phillies fans will be happy to learn that fireball reliever Billy Wagner’s era since 9/12 was a too hot to handle self-immolating 5.40.

The Face of Defeat

A sudden decline

A terrific graphic from the Washington Post illustrating how the Phillies made up 7 games (really 8 when you count the final standings) since September 17th. Hint: Mets 5-12, Phils 13-4.

The Collapse is Complete

From the front page of today’s Washington Post.

 

“Collapse is Complete, and the Mets are History”

Sunday, September 30, 2007

J-Roll

Here's some New York props for Jimmy Rollins, courtesy of the NY Times' Jere Longman:

"As the regular season winds down, with three home games against Washington, he has delivered the best year of his career and perhaps has become the league's most complete shortstop.

Rollins is the first major leaguer to have at least 200 hits, 15 triples, 25 home runs and 25 stolen bases in one season. He is also only the third everyday shortstop to hit 30 homers and steal 30 bases in a season, joining Barry Larkin in 1996 and Alex Rodriguez in 1998.

Rollins ranks first in the N.L. in runs scored (136), at-bats (704), multihit games (62) and triples (19). He began the day tied for second in hits with 207 before adding to his total and drawing within one at-bat of the single-season record of 705, set by Willie Wilson of Kansas City in 1980.

'Thirty homers, Gold Glove at shortstop, steals bases, hits for average — yeah, I'd say you could make a case he's as good as there is,' Atlanta Manager Bobby Cox said of Rollins."


I'm predicting a big game from #11 this afternoon.

Playoffs? Playoffs?

Playoffs? Playoffs! I still don't understand how the Diamondbacks have clinched the West when the Padres are one game back before Sunday's games.

If the Mets and Phillies both win today (and I'm guessing both will, though I think the Mets will have the harder time going against Dontrelle Willis who is 5-0 at Shea Stadium), then they will have exact reverse home/away records. With wins, the Phillies will be 47-34 at home and 42-39 on the road. On the flip side, the Mets will be 42-39 at home and 47-34 on the road. Note: if both teams win the playoff game will be in Philadelphia tomorrow. According to their season long records, that is exactly how both teams would want it. Of course, given those records it is more likely that that the Mets will lose at home today and the Phillies win at home.

My friend Shuff - a Mets and Giants fan - is going to the New York "doubleheader." The Mets game at 1pm and the Eagles-Giants at 8pm. Here's hoping the Phillies clinch by 5:00pm and the Eagles can deliver the knockout blow to NY fandom tonight.

Pressure

Nationally acclaimed baseball columnist Thomas Boswell writes up the pressure the Phillies felt and didn't handle well as the first-place team and with its playoff destiny in its own hands. Charlie Manuel concurs. "Asked if he thought his team had shown any signs of being 'tight,' Manuel broke every rule and told the truth. 'Maybe in the seventh we did,' he said, bless his honest heart," Boswell writes.

Manuel Alternative

So my brother responded that he didn't have a problem batting Hamels in the bottom of the seventh with the bases loaded and two out so that you could send Hamels out to pitch the 8th. My bro pointed out that he - and likely Manuel - has no confidence in most members of the bullpen - aside from Myers and Romero.

My brother, Jeff, also pointed out that the bullpen needed a rest and with Eaton starting yesterday that the bullpen would likely be called upon for lots of innings. That last point was prescient as Eaton didn't last three innings. And for this we're paying $8 million a year.

Friday, September 28, 2007

Manuel Incompetent or Dangerous?

Can someone explain to me why Charlie let Cole Hamels bat with 2 outs, the bases loaded, and a 6-0 lead in the bottom of the 7th tonight?

I would have thought it was an obvious pinch hitter situation. What with your staff ace pitching 7 strong innings in his second start back from the disabled list, and with an opportunity to truly blow the game wide open.

I know the bullpen needed a rest, but if Manuel had pinch hit for Hamels - and the sub made the final out - couldn't you still reasonably expect Condrey, Alfonseca, and/or Geary to have gotten the necessary six outs and protected a 6 run lead?

I simply don't understand why he let Hamels hit in that situation and why he let him go out for the 8th. Sure he was cruising and had a shutout going, but he wound up throwing 116 pitches. This after his last start he was on a strict 75 pitch pitch count. If the Phillies do make the playoffs, and their magic number is now 2, Hamels is going to get plenty of work. in fact, it looks like he would probably start the division series or at worst game two. and from then on out, he's probably on short rest. so, again, i'm not sure why you don't pinch hit for him in the 7th - with the bases loaded - and why you let him throw 116 pitches. Come to think of it, there may be an argument for not having him pitch the 7th either.

Am i missing something?

Magic #2

The Phils just slingshotted past the Mets. Tied for first yesterday, and now with Hamels' win and another Mets' loss tonight the Phils' magic number is now 2. Simply amazing.

Though come to think of it. I thought that yesterday the Mets' magic number was 3. After last night's games that put the Phils in a tie for 1st I would have thought that that too would have made the Phillies' magic number 3. And with a 6-0 win and another Mets loss, that would have made the magic number 1. But there are two games left and the Phils only have a one game lead so I guess the magic number is 2.

Center of Attention

Interview with Eagles’ center Jamaal Jackson. He and his linemates’ goal is to keep #5 “clean” and wonders why B. Westbrook isn’t mentioned in the same breath as LDT and Shaun Alexander as a candidate for best back in the NFL. Some surprisingly hardball questions posed, but Jackson handles them deftly… or is that deflectedly.

Let Us Pray

Kansas City Chief Elmo Wright is generally acknowledged as the first player to perform a touchdown celebration in 1973. But it is the Philadelphia Eagles’ own Herb Lusk who gets credit for the first prayer after touchdown in 1977. Who knew. The Washington Post profiles Lusk who, to his credit, is now a pastor in downtown Philly.

Fly, Eagles, Fly

The Eagles’ fight song gets an entry in Wikipedia elaborating on its creation and rebirth under Jeff Lurie.

Miscellaneous

I’m surprised there hasn’t been more made of Ryan Howard setting the single season strikeout record. Funny how 44 homers and 130 RBIs will give you the benefit of the doubt. And since you are wondering, the most strikeouts Mike Schmidt had in a season was 180 in 1975.

And even having struck out an astounding 32% of the time this year, Howard’s on-base percentage is still .391 – the 3rd highest among regular, everyday players in the Phillies lineup (behind Utley and Burrell. I’m not counting Werth).

Speaking of records, Jimmy Rollins will break the single season major league record for at bats this weekend. He’s currently at 704.

Finally, I watched the season premier of The Office last night. The funniest line had to be “I’m stitious, just not superstitious.” Also, were viewers aware before that wunderkind Ryan’s last name is Howard, making him Ryan Howard? This tidbit may have been known to diehard fans of the show, but it was highlighted last night on his desk nameplate. The Office have some writers who are Phillies fans?

Where are the White CBs?

Here’s an interesting twist on the recent NFL black quarterback race debate. Mark Kriegel touches base with Jason Sehorn, the last white cornerback to play in the NFL.

 

Sehorn’s take on McNabb’s comments: “It's not the color of your skin. It's the city you play in." Ouch.

 

“We played the Eagles twice a year and they never had a great wide receiver. But the one year they give him a great wide receiver — even if he was a malcontent — he gets them to the Super Bowl. And then what?," asks Sehorn. Double Ouch.

 

Read it all here, “Is the White CB Gone for Good?”

Thursday, September 27, 2007

Fate and Destiny

It's now all tied up with three games to go. As the radio guys observed tonight, this is as close the Phillies have gotten to first place since before their season started (the Mets won a game the day before the Phillies opener).

Their fate is now in their hands. Here's hoping destiny is also on board.

Epic Collapse?

“The Mets recently led by 7 games with 17 to go. No team has ever failed to reach the postseason after being so far ahead that close to the end. If the Mets don’t make it, this will be seen as an epic collapse, particularly given New York histrionics and high expectations,” writes the Times’ George Vecsey.

 

Would such a collapse, to the ultimate benefit of the Philadelphia Phillies, exorcise the demons of 1964 and prompt future sports writers to reference not the ’64 Phils but the 2007 Mets as a symbol of choke artistry par excellence?

From the Mouth of Clinton Portis

“I go out on the field and I give it everything I've got, bro. That's what I try to do. I'ma try to help the Washington Redskins as much as I can, as long as I can, and do whatever I can. When my number is not called, I'm not one to pout. Everybody want me to be a pouter. Everybody want me to be, 'Oh give me the ball.' They know I want the ball. Who don't know Clinton Portis want the ball? What you think, I shy away.”

-          - Clinton Portis, Redskins RB, trying to explain why he wasn’t on the field for the final two unsuccessful goal line running plays in last week’s 24-17 loss to the Giants. Interestingly, the Washington Post recently came under fire for cleaning up Portis’ quotes so they read more like actual English in the paper. Now I see why.

Real Life Replacements


In the Gene Hackman-Keanu Reeves film, the Washington Sentinel replacement cheerleaders (from the Pussycat Club) distract the opposing team with their sideline “routines.” Now, former Texans GM Charley Casserly is reporting that the NFL has warned teams not to direct their cheer squads from warming up, stretching or…cheer near the opposing team’s sideline during pre-game warm-ups. Seems some of the players were becoming distracted.

Homefield advantage?

Maybe the best thing about this division race and the implosion of the Mets is the face of absolute bewilderment on the face of Mets’ fans at Shea Stadium. Did you see their catatonic stares last night as their team squandered a 5-0 lead (and a 6-2 lead) to the Nats, who on paper are one of the worst teams in baseball this year but are showing plenty of fight in games played against both the Phillies and Mets.

 

At this point, I’m not sure the Mets have an advantage playing before the hometown fans as the Cardinals come to town. The pressure on them is going to be intense. And if the Cards actually get a lead or win tonight, the pressure will be futher ratcheted up.

 

On the other hand, it is tremendous to see the crowds at Citizens Bank Park which are giving the players an opportunity to see how pumped the stands can get and how exciting meaningful baseball games in September and October can be in Philadelphia.

 

Let’s keep waving those towels.

Patriot Spying Cover Up?

The NFL “investigation” of the NE Patriots’ sideline videotaping took a bizarre turn last week when the league announced that the investigation was concluded and all materials – including videotapes – submitted to the league by the Pats had been destroyed. Say what?

 

In most other realms, such material would be considered “evidence.” And as anyone who has ever watched a TV crime show knows, you never destroy evidence. Unless you are trying to hide something – even if it is the prosecutor doing the shredding.

 

I’ve written before about the half-baked  job Roger Goodell has done on this whole scandal. The fine and draft pick sanctions that look tougher than they really are (Belichick’s $500,000 fine is only 12.5% of his annual salary. And at $4 million per he’s not going to have to forego the Maserati because of the fine. The Pats lost a pick, but lower picks if they actually make the playoffs, and even then they will have a first round draft pick – San Fran’s).


But the actual investigation was kangaroo court. It was conducted hastily – Belichick’s fine was imposed less than a week after the known taping incident occurred. No press reports indicate that the league interviewed anyone on the Patriots’ coaching, recording, or stadium staff other than Belichick and maybe owner Robert Kraft. Weirdly, Goodell didn’t bother to call in Eric Mangini a former Pats coach whose team Belichick was taping and would be in a position to know the history and use of the videotapes. Nor did the NFL bring in any current or former Pats players to inquire about how the tapes might have been used to gain an advantage in a game.

 

Now comes word that the NFL, in the process of its investigation, collected all the taping evidence from the Pats and immediately destroyed it.

 

The question becomes why? Was that the ultimate purpose of the “investigation?” Why get rid of the evidence so quickly? Why get rid of the evidence at all? And why not explain or describe what the league found on the Patriots’ materials.

 

At the very least, the NFL’s actions give the appearance of a cover up. But again, why would the most savvy professional sports league make itself look like it is hiding something?

 

The explosive answer is, cause it actually is trying to hide something. Evidence of the Patriots cheating in any or all of their Super Bowl “wins.”

 

ESPN’s Tuesday Morning Quarterback poses it thusly: “The lack of answers leaves several questions hanging out there. Chief among them: Is it possible the Patriots' tapes showed some evidence of New England cheating in a Super Bowl?”

 

In fact, read the entire TMQ column where Gregg Easterbrook lays out the questionable timeline of events, the Patriots surprising lack of cooperation in the probe, and his repeated questions to the NFL spokesman, complete with the spokesman’s evasions and non-denial denials, about this potentially explosive possibility.

 

Here are the key issues from TMQ: “After Aiello twice declined to say what the Patriots' materials showed, I heard from him a third time Sunday. He wrote in an e-mail that my assumption the tapes contained indications of Super Bowl cheating is "wrong," then wrote, "There is no such evidence regarding the Patriots' Super Bowl victories." So, is this the denial that I've been seeking? But wait: Three days earlier, the NFL destroyed the evidence. I asked Aiello whether he meant there is no evidence now of New England cheating in a Super Bowl -- that is, after the destruction of the files -- or whether examination of the materials positively affirmed no cheating. He did not reply.

 

Aiello's " On Sunday, Sept. 16, NFL commissioner Roger Goodell went on national TV and promised he would get to the bottom of the Patriots' sign-stealing. Four days later, the NFL announced all videotapes and other spying materials compiled by the Patriots had been obtained by the league and destroyed. Goodell, who until then had been very upfront in addressing the Beli-Cheat scandal, didn't go back on television to say what the tapes contained; the commissioner has been in radio silence about the Patriots since the files arrived at the NFL's Park Avenue headquarters. The league acted in a hurry to dispose of damning documents, but has not revealed what was in the tapes and notes, nor said why there was a rush to get rid of them….There is no such evidence" phrasing calls to mind what Richard Nixon's attorney general John Mitchell dubbed the "non-denial denial," an assertion that seems to say something but doesn't. On Sunday, I asked Aiello whether the league would make a simple, declarative statement that the spying files proved the Patriots did not cheat in a Super Bowl -- and have not heard back from him. I assume this is not because he has forgotten: I've heard from Park Avenue sources that the fact I am asking these questions is very much on the NFL's radar. I have known Aiello professionally for years and, like others who deal with him, have always found him skilled, knowledgeable and forthright. It's very odd to be getting a "non-denial denial" from him now.

 

I further asked Aiello who had examined the New England materials before they were destroyed, and he would answer only "senior members of the league office staff." I asked when the materials actually arrived at league headquarters -- How long were they there before being destroyed? -- and he would not answer. I asked whether the materials had been inspected by anyone conversant with the game plans and signals the Rams, Panthers and Eagles used against Bill Belichick's Patriots in the Super Bowl; football signs and terminology are cryptic, so it would help to have a skilled eye. Aiello wouldn't answer that. I asked who had ordered the tapes and notes destroyed, and he wouldn't answer that, either.

 

And I asked, if there was nothing incriminating in the New England documents, why was the league in such a hurry to shred them? First, Aiello wrote, "The purpose of destroying the tapes and related documents was to eliminate any advantage they might have given the Patriots going forward and ensure a level playing field for all 32 teams." But the league announced last week that the Patriots "certified in writing" that no copies of the materials exist. If the sole copies of the sign-stealing materials had been sent to the league office, it would be impossible for these materials to give the Patriots any advantage. When I pointed that out, Aiello countered that the reason for the destruction was "so that our clubs would know they no longer exist and cannot be used by anyone." Again, if the sole copies were being held by the league, how could any club use the material?”

 

Lost amid all of this efforts to protect the Patriots and the league’s “integrity” is the fact that the NFL is doing a disservice to its other members – in particular the Panthers, Rams, and Eagles – who may have been victims of the Patriots nefarious and duplicitous cheating. The NFL owes as much to these teams as it does the Patriots – regardless of how much Roger Goodell owes his job to Robert Kraft. The next big question becomes why are the Panthers, Rams, and Eagles owners seeking to get to the bottom of it all?  

 

 

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

Good Riddance Gillick

So Pat Gillick has announced that he will retire after the 2008 season. Presumably, he will declare "victory" should the Phillies managed to get into the post-season next week or next year.

It looks to many like Gillick is just getting out ahead of the scrutiny. Ironically, several friends and I were trading emails last week before the announcement debating whether Gillick should be fired.

Cause when you scratch just below the surface of this team and the GM's extraordinarily questionable moves, it appears that this team might make the playoffs not because of Gillick but in spite of him.

Seriously. Shouldn't Gillick be canned for the simple fact of thinking that Freddy Garcia or Adam Eaton were the preseason solutions to the Phillies pitching problems? I can, almost, understand taking a flyer on Garcia. But they signed Eaton to a 3-year $24 million contract that the Phils will be on the hook for until the year after Gillick leaves. Eaton's getting $8 million per for a 9-9 record and a 6.36 ERA?! He's quite possibly the worst starting pitcher in the National League
and/or all of baseball.

As my brother noted, "Gillick has to be accountable. [Besides the Garcia and Eaton debacles] add in Barajas and Helms as our starters and he's done a terrible job. Fortunately Dobbs and Ruiz have done a great job as has Werth the 2nd half of year. Barajas and Helms have been a HUGE waste of money. And Gillick has gotten lucky, very lucky, w/ Pat the Bat's production after trying to shop him all offseason. Burrell has been very good the past 2-3 months. Not exactly $15 million good, but he has produced like a major leaguer."

In some ways, the pitching injuries may have saved Gillick. Think about it. If Garcia had to pitch the entire year he might have worse numbers than Eaton. And then even more focus/criticism comes on Gillick for bringing in such a stiff.

With Lieber and Garcia hurt, Gillick is kind of protected by scrutiny cause the starting staff that is out there now is not the one that Gillick put together to start the season. that and everyone is just thrilled that Kendrick can go six innings and not get shelled.

The one savvy move I did like (other than keeping Moyer) was holding onto Lieber rather than trading him at the start of the season when he was odd man out of the rotation. That looked like a good move when all the injuries hit. I liked it as protection and I liked it as a trading chip down the road for bullpen help. Of course, with all the walking wounded that didn't pan out as planned.

Still, relying on Gordon (who did no one any favors by keeping his aching shoulder from LAST July a secret, thanks Tom!) and planning on bolstering your bullpen in mid season by making a trade was the plan all along? Ultimately capped by sticking your opening day starter in
the bullpen.

As my friend PK observed, "can anyone name a single thing in the Gillick Era that was a great move? I can't remember when they traded Thome for Rowand, because that was the last great move this organization made.

Bringing in Jamie Moyer was savvy, I'd say, since he's a guaranteed 14 wins or so and a guy who just pretty much will always keep his team in games; yeah, somtimes he gives up 5 runs in 7 innings, but then look at his last 2 starts: 7 innings, 2 runs; 6 innings, 1 run. Of course, this wasn't sheer briliance, just a nice move.

Otherwise, every critical player that's on the team now doing good-to-great things -- Howard, Utley, Rollins, Burrell, Victorino, Hamels, Myers -- was already in the organization.

All the injuries suffered to the rotation are brutal (who'd've thunk we'd miss Lieber this badly?) are not really Gillick's fault. But I tell you what is his fault, for sure: the bullpen. That bullpen was barren at the start of the season we had to take our No. 1 pitcher and put him there.

That's clearly Gillick's fault."

I would add that even the Thome-Rowand deal (and I can't recall if that was a Gillick move or not) but if it was, was one done in desperation as evidence by the

Phils paying SOOOO much of Thome's salary just to get him out of town.

Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Gay Wolverines


The biggest question coming out of Sunday's game was why Jeff Lurie would have selected those ridiculous 1933 throwback uniforms to "celebrate" the 75th team anniversary. Perhaps an even bigger question is why any fan would have bothered to buy such a hideous jersey - and judging from the number of blue/yellow shirts in the stands, a surprising number did just that.

The whole throwback uniform has been overdone, though not apparently oversold. First you had the home and away jerseys. Then the "alternate" jerseys, which in most cases - like the Eagles - meant incorporating black into the outfit. Now you've got the throwback uni. It's getting absurd. But not as absurd as the choice itself. Keith Olbermann on Sunday Night Football took the Eagles' retro look and the Lurie to task for the ugliness of the uniform and hit the larger problem on the head - merchandising. And by the way, if you are going to needlessly tempt the fans with extraneous merchandising, at least select the 60's era green and white uniforms or the late 70's darker green and silver look. (The 90's kelly green is still relatively recent to be considered a "throwback" jersey.)

Just as bad, the Eagles players themselves - while being good employees in not trashing the 1933 look publicly - looked like a high school team. As one friend said days before the Eagles game. How unfortunate you are 0-2 and facing a must win at home and you have to take the field looking like that.

But the best line about the uniforms came from my friend TD. In the stands just after the Eagles had taken the field on Sunday, he observed, "My God, they look like the gay Michigan Wolverines."

Monday, September 24, 2007

McNabb's Keith Hernandez Game

I am hard-pressed to think of a singularly stellar athletic performance against such a backdrop of controversies and questions as the one by Donovan McNabb yesterday. Pressure? In a must win game for the 0-2 team, in the aftermath of the controversy about his HBO remarks about QBs and race, and the very real questions that were raised about the condition of his rehabilitated knee and whether his career was hastening to an end, Donovan McNabb made a statement on the field. Well, not exactly a statement. More like a declaration. Actually several bold declarations… with exclamation points:

 

“I’m Donovan McNabb!”

 

“Never Underestimate Me!”

 

“THIS TEAM WILL ALWAYS – ALWAYS- BE IN CONTENTION SO LONG AS I’M THE STARTING QUARTERBACK!!!!!!”

 

21-26. 381 yards. 4 TDs. No interceptions. A perfect passer rating of 156.3.

 

Of course, the 1st half numbers were even more impressive. 332 yards passing, only one incomplete, and 3 TD passes

 

The smattering of boos that greeted #5 during his introduction had all turned to cheers by the end of the 1st quarter.

Seriously, has there ever been a more complete offensive quarter and/or half of football under Andy Reid than the one yesterday? The McNabb naysayers, who were scurrying back into their little holes by 2:00 pm EDT yesterday afternoon, will no doubt suggest that the Lions defense was hardly a true test. 300 passing yards in one half against a professional football team is impressive by any standard. And the Lions were 2-0 coming into this game. McNabb and the Eagles scored 42 points in the first half. No other team in the league scored as many points as that in an entire games yesterday. It was dominating and McNabb was awesome. So were K. Curtis, B. Westbrook, and the defense. But the star of yesterday’s show was Donovan McNabb.

 

More about later.  

 

Friday, September 21, 2007

Washington Support for McNabb

The Washington Post’s Michael Wilbon comes to Donovan McNabb’s defense about #5’s recent HBO remarks with a nice historical perspective on the NFL, QB, and race and some very strong words about the hostility McNabb faces from his own fans. He ends with a rebuke of the historical ignorance of the younger black QBs in the league and plea for them to take a stand just like – or even express appreciation for - their predecessors.

 

Writes Wilbon: “Thankfully, Donovan McNabb had the guts to stand tall in the pocket with critics trying to knock his head off. Thankfully, McNabb, at 30, has some sense of the NFL beyond his own participation. Most celebrity athletes talk only when paid to talk, and usually about something benign if not downright useless…

 

Anybody who doubts McNabb needs only to walk around one of the upper-concourse areas of Lincoln Financial Field late in a game when, as several white friends have told me, the frequent use of the word "nigger" preceding McNabb's name during a losing performance is so casual it sickens them. Rex Grossman, just to name one white quarterback who has to deal with daily criticism, doesn't have to be on the wrong end of that kind of hateful venom, even though he'll never be half the quarterback McNabb has been.”

 

Note: I have witnessed similar epithets used to describe McNabb at the Linc, and it similarly sickens me.

LJ Out

ESPN is reporting that Eagles’ TE LJ Smith has had surgery to clear out his sports hernia and will be unavailable for Sunday’s game. Too bad for LJ as it limits his playing time in a contract year. On the other hand, this will probably help him and the Eagles in the long-run, and by that I mean later this season. LJ was running around like an old man out on the field, obviously impacted by his groin and hernia injuries. Better to have a healthy Matt Schobel and rookie Brent Celek playing in his stead till he can make a better recovery.

Detroit End of Road for McNabb?

Can Detroit deliver the coup de grace to Donovan McNabb’s tenure as the Eagles starting QB on Sunday? This Motor City columnist thinks so.

 

Writes Drew Sharp: “The Lions find themselves in that rare position of quarterback executioner. They’re usually the ones facing the firing squad, wearing the requisite blindfold along with protruding cigarette.

 

But they can expedite Donovan McNabb’s exit from Philadelphia with a stunning victory over the Eagles on Sunday.

 

McNabb is done in Philly if the Lions embarrass him, administering the final insult.

 

He’s standing alone right now, a victim of poor timing more than anything else. McNabb didn’t back down from his HBO comments in which he stated that despite improved opportunities, black quarterbacks remain scrutinized much greater than their white counterpart”

 

And this, “And Philadelphia has accurately earned its reputation of eating its own.”

The "C" Word

As in Collapse.

 

Here’s the lede in today’s NY Times’ sports section: “As mortified fans watch the Mets fritter away their once-commanding grip on first place in the National League East, dread infects the city that it might be witnessing a collapse of unprecedented proportions.”

 

Bigger than the ’64 Phillies? We’ll see. But I have it on good authority from my Washington, DC political reporter friend PK that Kentucky Senator Jim Bunning’s office is fielding a surge of press phone calls asking for his recollections of the last two weeks of the 1964 season.

Fan of the Week


You won't see this pic on the Eagles' website.

Hint: take a closer look at the "jersey."

Teddy Ballgame


Appropos of nothing, I came across this really cool picture courtesy of Time Magazine of Ted Williams ready to enter the batter box at Fenway Park.

Thursday, September 20, 2007

Holy Cow

oh my God. the Marlins just beat the Mets in the 10th after blowing the 4 run lead, then rallying for 3 in the bottom of the 9th to tie it and now scoring in the 10th!

Sheridan and McNabb

Phil Sheridan is giving Rich Hoffman a run for his money as the best sports columnist in city with another stellar article in today's paper about Donovan McNabb and his HBO comments about race.

This superb piece had nuance and insight, and was as thought-provoking about McNabb and race as #5's initial comments. The nut graph as far as I'm concerned (and this goes beyond race commentary and neatly summarizes McNabb's star-crossed career in Philadelphia):

"McNabb's dubious status as the most peculiarly criticized professional athlete in the country.

That's most peculiarly criticized, not most criticized. Many athletes take heat for their performances, for the things they say and do, for their off-the-field actions. Some of them bring heavy criticism on themselves with bad behavior or ignorant public comments.

McNabb has been a very good player and a model citizen throughout his Eagles career. And yet he has been at the center of strange episodes involving Rush Limbaugh, who said he was coddled by the media because he was black; Terrell Owens, who insinuated that McNabb was not black enough; and the head of the local NAACP, who wrote a screed essentially calling McNabb a traitor to his race."


And on the larger score of McNabb's coments, let me say. Sadly, I think McNabb has some valid points and legitimate arguments about the unique challenges by black QBs in the NFL. My own personal experience is that people who criticize McNabb - and some of these people are my friends - invariably bring up his race, usually accompanied by a racial slur. There is very real anger towards McNabb from these naysayers (perhaps why I personally maybe overcompensate in his favor as a fan) and I can't help but detect at least a whiff of racial animus. I hope - and prefer to think - that the anger stems in large part from frustration because of McNabb's incredible talents and how close he has come to winning a championship for this team and city, but there is no denying there is an anger and an edge that simply is not there when talking about other white Eagles' or NFL QBs.

Wednesday, September 19, 2007

Barkley

I can't believe Sir Charles was in the MNF booth for the entire 3rd quarter... Especially after he made his point - philly is tough sports town & d-mac should get a multi year pass for all that he has accomplished - and then endlessly repeated it. Jaws didn't help things by rehashing his unceremonious dumping and his sometimes rough treatment by the fans. Of course, leave it to Barkley to get off two great lines: the first about asking management to get "Shack" and then playing with Charles Shackleford, and the second about a player "being the future" and Barkley pointing out that games are played in the present. I can't decide if that is mundane or profound, though i'm leaning towards the latter.

And what was with the Tony Kornheiser/Michael Wilbon split screen PTI halftime show? They were in the same stadium! They could't get in the same booth?

Upon Further Review

More on this tomorrow, but I rewatched the Redskins game again and i must say, i'm a little more encouraged about the offense than i was at the time. The offense did start to click in the 4th quarter and McNabb did make some really good throws. Particularly on 3rd and 4th downs to keep drives alive. Sure he badly misthrew some balls, but that's what you always get with McNabb. Only this time instead of the passes being fired into the dirt at the feet of receivers, some were high and some were just completely off target.

Pass protection was adequate, but the play calling was questionable. I also have issues with the routes the WR run. There were alot of plays where there was not a single receiver running a deep route, certainly nothing longer than 15 yards - and most of those were square ins or outs. Can't at least one WR "go long?" Perhaps that's because the Eagles' don't have a true speedster (i don't count Curtis in that club). Which then begs the question, why don't they? Why don't they have a guy like Santana Moss whose a home run hitter and puts the fear of God in CBs and safeties? How hard is it to draft or bring a FA WR who runs really, really fast? That is all on Andy Reid.

Then again, in the one play where every wideout went on a fly pattern - the play where McNabb overthrew Curtis down the left sideline and into double/triple coverage, it looked to me that Hank Baskett beat his man and was breaking free on a post pattern down the middle of the field.

Democratic Wussies

Here's just the latest example of the wussies that pass for "leaders" in the Democratic party. Florida University student Andrew Meyer got into a heated q&a exchange with presidential loser and still junior Massachusetts Senator John Kerry to the point where police escorted Meyer from the event. Here's the story here.

But the big story is that Meyer, while lying prone and being subdued by five (5!) police officers and with what looked like handcuffs on was then tasered (!) by police.

You can see the video of the whole spectacle here on youtube. When you view it, though, try to remain focused on the audio and Kerry's voice. A student is being taken away by at least five police officers, is being held down in the middle of an auditorium aisle, and then tasered.....all while John Kerry is droning on in the background, seemingly oblivious to the police brutality occurring 25 feet away and directly in front of him - which all occurs because a student got exercised in asking him some heated questions.

Again, Kerry does nothing. After the event, his office put out some lame statement about how he has never seen such a thing in 30 years in public office, and how he hopes neither police nor students were injured (remember: Kerry witnessed this kid getting tasered). Is it any wonder this clown couldn't muster a response to some Swift Boat ads or that he asked for swiss cheese on his cheesesteak during a campaign stop in Philadelphia, or that his idea of "biking" is riding some effeminate tour de france type 20 speed.

Alas, Kerry and his response, or lack thereof, is just par for the course with Democrats lo these long days.

The Democratic Party. Without balls since Lyndon Johnson.


Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Post-Mortem

Sorry, I've been out of commission today with a bad stomach virus or some bad wings i ate last night. Then again, my naseaousness could stem from that wretched Eagles performance last night.

A couple of thoughts before I get to my friend's perspective.
1) As bad as things looked last night, it is still a long season. This team is still capable of getting to 10-6.
2) McNabb is clearly not 100%. I would guesstimate at about 60-75%. Given that, it is sadistic for Andy Reid to call so many passing plays. It hearkens back to McNabb's sports hernia and bruised sternum when they called 50 pass plays in games the Eagles were winning.
3) Given the number of pass plays called, and the lack of offensive rythym, i'm guessing that Reid has recalled the play calling from Morhninweg. That's too bad, though the results speak for themselves.
4) Anyone remember the Eagles-Redskins game at FedEx two years ago? That was the game TO was suspended from and McNabb had the sports hernia. The last two minutes of last night's game reminded me of that game. The Eagles driving for a tying score, even down to the direction the team was driving as viewed on TV. And like that game, the Eagles came up short (actually, as i recall Arrington intercepted McNabb in that game in Washington).
5) Taylor and Landry are big hitters and I think Landry will be a big star in this league.
6) Speaking of Taylor, shouldn't he have been called for spearing when he drove the crown of his helmet into B. Westbrook's back as Westbrook was running out of bounds in one of the Eagles last drives?
7) Jason Campbell looked like the real deal last night. Cooley should have made a couple of catches, though he overthrew Moss on what would have been the game clincher.
8) Then again, if the Eagles had actually made TDs instead of FGs last night, they would have won - even with the poor performance.
9) Apparently we've returned to an offense where our WRs can't get separation. but the stranger part is the total lack of rushing options beyond Westbrook. And why was Tony Hunt inactivated?

Now on to an email from my angry friend PK:

48-17

In case anyone's wondering, that's the play-calling breakdown from the game tonight: Donovan threw 46 passes, plus he ran 2 plays in which a pass was called and he scrambled for runs, and they ran the ball just 17 times to westbrook and ran it to no one else at all. Period. That's 73% of the plays called for passes.

Oh shoot, this doesn't account for the 3 or 4 sacks, so it's actually more than 50 pass plays to 17 running plays, so it's at least 75% of all plays were called as pass plays. So much for last year's Marty Offense. The Mad Scientist Andy is back in charge.

Anyone who wants to know why we lost tonight, it's that simple. Andy Reid continues to wreak havoc on this organization. It's insanity. He is a madman during these games, it is some sort of psychotic reaction to losing the Super Bowl after he called more than 60 pass plays and took a lot of heat for it. It's nuts, it's crazy. It's bizarre.

The other reason, of course, why we lost is because Andy and management simply decided that the Thrash-Pinkston model of receivers, from all those painful days of yesteryear, was a good enough idea to go back to; man, somehow Reggie Brown has simply regressed himself into Pinkston.

No, the season's not over, this division is so unbelievably god awful that it's not over. But any thoughts that this is a team that is capable of winning the Super Bowl -- probably done. Offensively they look like the early '03 offense, which simply sputtered around doing absolute crap till November, but back then we also had a 3-headed monster power running game that, collectively, ran the ball 340 times for 1,700 yards and something like 18 TDs.

There is no running game this year to fall back on like there was in '03.

Sometimes, one of the amazing things I've actually come to realize over the last few years, the fans really are as smart or smarter than management, that management doesn't really know a whole lot more about the game than a fan who really does pay attention.

Monday, September 17, 2007

He's the Man, They're the Team, to Beat

Before the region’s sports fans go gaga over the results of tonight’s Eagles game, I wanted to pause for just a moment to recognize the extraordinary accomplishments of Jimmy Rollins. He took a lot of heat, especially in New York, for declaring the Phillies were the team to beat this season. Sure the Mets may wind up winning the division. Heck, the Phillies may not even make the playoffs. But it turns out that at least in the NL East the Phillies were the team to beat, and the Mets couldn’t do it. The Phillies were 12-6 against the Mets this year, including three (3!) series sweeps. As they are fond of saying in NY, “amazing!”

Of course, dominance like that just doesn’t happen. And a large part of those victories was SS Jimmy Rollins, or as he should be called in the clubhouse, “The Man.”

Jim Salisbury points out that “In 18 games against the Mets this season, Rollins was 28 for 81, an average of .346, with four doubles, two triples, six homers and 15 RBIs.” That, my friends is production. Production when it matters against the best team in the division. And considering that half those games were being played in New York where Rollins received considerable abuse….well, again, simply amazing.

Jimmy Rollins talked the talk. And backed it up by walking the walk. You heard it here first. If the Phillies can make the playoffs then look out. Rollins could be ready for a Lenny Dykstra-like post-season performance and carry the team and the entire city on his back to the World Series.

 

 

Change of Heart

A friend of mine who is a Redskins fan told me the other day that he had a “feeling” the Skins would beat the Eagles. Upon further reflection, he has changed my mind and now thinks the “Skins lose big tonight.”

Why the change of heart, I asked? Jansen’s injury and the possibility of Juqua Thomas and Jevon Kearse crushing Campbell from the right side?

No, he said. “I don't know. I think Wade will do a good job over there at RT, i'm just losing confidence in Campbell playing well in front of the most hostile crowd in the NFL on Monday night.”

True.

Mama Portis better watch out tonight.

 

Opposing Viewpoint

The Washington Post looks at the Eagles:

 

“There is no way truly to prepare to face Jim Johnson's blitz-tastic defense. It's impossible to mimic all of his nuances and predict how much pressure Philadelphia's defensive coordinator will bring at anytime and from where it will originate.”

 

And some stats:

Eagles defensive coordinator Jim Johnson has made his mark over the past seven seasons. How the Eagles rank during his tenure:

Category

No.

Rank

Third-Down Efficiency

33.8%

2nd

Red Zone Touchdown Pct.

44.1%

2nd

Points Per Game

17.4

3rd

Total Sacks

305

3rd

Total Takeaways

212

8th

 

More on the NE Patriot Act...

i.e., videotaping and wiretapping.

 

1)      The investigation continues? Pete King writes that Goodell continues to seek videotape from the Patriots and if they don’t fully comply the penalty the commish imposed could be increased.

2)      More on the King article here – is the nonsensical reason Goodell gives for NOT suspending Belichick. King hints that if Belichick were a short-timer he would have been suspended. What has that go to do with the price of tea in China?

3)      Even more ludicrous is this Goodell answer to a surprising hardball question from NFL company man King: “I said to him,” King writes, “assuming New England makes the playoffs, ‘The Patriots still have a first-round pick, and they still have four first-day picks in the draft.’' Said Goodell: ‘Right. But what about the pick they don't have? What if that pick turns into Dan Marino or Darrell Green?’' Got that? Goodell thinks his sanctions of the Patriots are so severe cause the draft pick they lost could cost them a Hall of Fame player. I can see the headline now, “Goodell Sanctions Pats, Strips Team of Possible Dan Marino.” But other than that, Goodell’s “punishment” will still leave the Pats with four first-day draft choices. Wow, talk about harsh. Not.

4)      The NY Times drops this intriguing nugget into today’s story about Goodell’s rush to judgment: “NBC reported that the Patriots might have wired linemen to pick up the Jets’ offensive audibles.” What the?!?!?

5)      Why are people criticizing Mangini as a turncoat? Did he dime Belichick out? No. Only when the great Bill B. used the same illegal spy tape strategy on the Jets that Mangini presumably knew about/used from his days with the Pats did Mangenius bring it to NFL security’s attention. If anything, Mangini’s loyalty is still intact. In fact, why didn’t Goodell bring Mangini in to inquire about what he knew and when he knew it. The bigger fall guy here is Belichick who could/would still be taping this week if he had shown enough discretion to not use it against the one of the two head coaches in the league who knew to be on the lookout for it (Crennel being the other).

6)      I wonder how Goodell feels about the rumors of the Belichick contract extension. Talk about Bob Kraft giving a big F-U to the commish and standing by his man.